Top Picks
Oval Cut Halo Diamond Stud Earrings - 18K Rose Gold Vermeil
MEGAN’S PICK EPI INTERNATIONAL LIMITEDOval Cut Halo Diamond Stud Earrings - 18K Rose Gold Vermeil
$330.00 EPI INTERNATIONAL LIMITED
2-Pairs: Women's Small Diamond Cubic Zirconia Earrings
FREYA’S PICK DAILY SALE, INC.2-Pairs: Women's Small Diamond Cubic Zirconia Earrings
$29.00 DAILY SALE, INC.
Gold Plated Brass Diamond Shape Clip Earrings
ROSIE’S PICK NATORIGold Plated Brass Diamond Shape Clip Earrings
$150.00 $60.00 NATORI
Sterling Silver Diamond Fascination Mystique 18K Gold-Plated Round Hoop Earrings
LEANNE’S PICK GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.Sterling Silver Diamond Fascination Mystique 18K Gold-Plated Round Hoop Earrings
$126.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
10K White Gold Diamond And Oval Sapphire Shepherd Hook Earrings
DANI’S PICK GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.10K White Gold Diamond And Oval Sapphire Shepherd Hook Earrings
$414.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
How we pick

These picks came from Megan, Freya, Rosie, Leanne and Dani, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $509 pieces
Worth the splurge16 pieces
14k Yellow Gold Emerald and Diamond Post Earrings
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

14k Yellow Gold Emerald and Diamond Post Earrings

$458.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Ss/Gold Plated Diamond Fascination Mystique Sterling Silver 18K Gold-Plated And Sapphire Hoop Earrings
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

Ss/Gold Plated Diamond Fascination Mystique Sterling Silver 18K Gold-Plated And Sapphire Hoop Earrings

$100.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Sterling Silver Diamond Fascination Mystique 18K Gold-Plated Round Hoop Earrings
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

Sterling Silver Diamond Fascination Mystique 18K Gold-Plated Round Hoop Earrings

$126.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
10K White Gold Diamond And Oval Sapphire Shepherd Hook Earrings
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

10K White Gold Diamond And Oval Sapphire Shepherd Hook Earrings

$414.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Soho Hoop Earrings
CRONJAGER

Soho Hoop Earrings

$286.00 CRONJAGER
10K Yellow Gold 1.5X30mm Diamond Cut Hoop Earrings
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

10K Yellow Gold 1.5X30mm Diamond Cut Hoop Earrings

$296.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
14K Yellow Gold Polished Diamond-Cut Hoop Earrings
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

14K Yellow Gold Polished Diamond-Cut Hoop Earrings

$335.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
14k White Gold Real Diamond Initial B Earrings
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

14k White Gold Real Diamond Initial B Earrings

$451.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
10K White Gold Diamond And Ruby Earrings
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

10K White Gold Diamond And Ruby Earrings

$470.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
14K Yellow Gold Diamond Fascination Diamond Dust/accent Hoop Earrings
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

14K Yellow Gold Diamond Fascination Diamond Dust/accent Hoop Earrings

$261.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
14k Yellow Gold Real Diamond Initial V Earrings
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

14k Yellow Gold Real Diamond Initial V Earrings

$347.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Oval Cut Halo Diamond Stud Earrings - 18K Rose Gold Vermeil
EPI INTERNATIONAL LIMITED

Oval Cut Halo Diamond Stud Earrings - 18K Rose Gold Vermeil

$330.00 EPI INTERNATIONAL LIMITED
10K Yellow Gold-Filled Diamond-Cut Hoop Earrings 24mm, 28mm
WJD EXCLUSIVES

10K Yellow Gold-Filled Diamond-Cut Hoop Earrings 24mm, 28mm

$169.00 WJD EXCLUSIVES
Brilliant Star Earrings (#7102)
W CONCEPT

Brilliant Star Earrings (#7102)

$212.00 W CONCEPT
Oval Cut Halo Diamond Stud Earrings - 18K Yellow Gold Vermeil
EPI INTERNATIONAL LIMITED

Oval Cut Halo Diamond Stud Earrings - 18K Yellow Gold Vermeil

$330.00 EPI INTERNATIONAL LIMITED
Shani Hoop Earrings in Blackberry smoke
RAMY BROOK

Shani Hoop Earrings in Blackberry smoke

$195.00 RAMY BROOK