Top Picks
Citizens of Humanity Gage Slim Straight Jeans - 32 Raven/Black
MAGGIE’S PICK SHOPBOPCitizens of Humanity Gage Slim Straight Jeans - 32 Raven/Black
$198.00 SHOPBOP
Tighter Tummy Fit High-Rise Boot Jean
ZARA’S PICK LANE BRYANTTighter Tummy Fit High-Rise Boot Jean
$109.79 $58.19 LANE BRYANT
Jane Jean 28"
ROSIE’S PICK ANINE BINGJane Jean 28"
$250.00 ANINE BING
GFTD LA Kevin Slim Rhinestone Denim Jeans
TAMSIN’S PICK DTLR-VILLAGFTD LA Kevin Slim Rhinestone Denim Jeans
$90.00 DTLR-VILLA
PAIGE Federal Transcend Slim Straight Jeans Black Shadow
ESME’S PICK SHOPBOPPAIGE Federal Transcend Slim Straight Jeans Black Shadow
$199.00 SHOPBOP
How we pick

Every collection on Came Saw Wore starts with a pile of products and ends with a short list chosen by real women. For black button fly slim jeans, that was Maggie, Zara, Rosie, Tamsin and Esme. They looked at shape, fabric, reviews where there were any and, honestly, whether it made them want to wear it this weekend. Things that look great on a model and terrible on a hanger tend to get cut. The full list underneath is everything that matched, from lots of different shops, so you can still have a proper browse.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $509 pieces
LEVI'S 721 Womens Jeans Black Slim Skinny Denim W26 L26 Raw Hem Zip
CERQULAR

LEVI'S 721 Womens Jeans Black Slim Skinny Denim W26 L26 Raw Hem Zip

$41.59 CERQULAR
LEVI'S Womens Black Slim Skinny Denim Jeans Cotton Blend W26 L27 Stretch Zip
CERQULAR

LEVI'S Womens Black Slim Skinny Denim Jeans Cotton Blend W26 L27 Stretch Zip

$41.59 CERQULAR
CALVIN KLEIN JEANS Womens Slim Black Denim Jeans W28 L32 Stylish Zip Closure
CERQULAR

CALVIN KLEIN JEANS Womens Slim Black Denim Jeans W28 L32 Stylish Zip Closure

$33.79 CERQULAR
LEVI'S Mile High Super Skinny Big E Womens Jeans Black Slim Skinny Denim W28 L30
CERQULAR

LEVI'S Mile High Super Skinny Big E Womens Jeans Black Slim Skinny Denim W28 L30

$41.59 CERQULAR
LEVI'S 721 Womens Jeans Black Slim Skinny Denim W26 L22 Zip Cotton Blend
CERQULAR

LEVI'S 721 Womens Jeans Black Slim Skinny Denim W26 L22 Zip Cotton Blend

$41.59 CERQULAR
DICKIES Womens Slim Black Jeans Cotton Blend Button W26 L26 Stylish
CERQULAR

DICKIES Womens Slim Black Jeans Cotton Blend Button W26 L26 Stylish

$37.69 CERQULAR
−91%THRT Shotgun Denim Jeans
DTLR-VILLA

THRT Shotgun Denim Jeans

$110.89 $9.98 DTLR-VILLA
−60%Calvin Klein Women's Mid Rise Flared Fit Jeans - Black
CALVIN KLEIN

Calvin Klein Women's Mid Rise Flared Fit Jeans - Black

$99.00 $39.60 CALVIN KLEIN
−29%Smoke Rise Distressed Knee Burst Slim Denim Jeans
DTLR-VILLA

Smoke Rise Distressed Knee Burst Slim Denim Jeans

$70.39 $49.98 DTLR-VILLA
$50 to $1008 pieces
GFTD LA Kevin Slim Rhinestone Denim Jeans
DTLR-VILLA

GFTD LA Kevin Slim Rhinestone Denim Jeans

$90.00 DTLR-VILLA
Baylen Mica Jeans
WILD OAK BOUTIQUE

Baylen Mica Jeans

$62.00 WILD OAK BOUTIQUE
Factory Eco Hawthorn Slim Jeans
GUESS FACTORY

Factory Eco Hawthorn Slim Jeans

$79.99 GUESS FACTORY
−47%Tighter Tummy Fit High-Rise Boot Jean
LANE BRYANT

Tighter Tummy Fit High-Rise Boot Jean

$109.79 $58.19 LANE BRYANT
−15%Wesley Flying Monkey Jeans
WILD OAK BOUTIQUE

Wesley Flying Monkey Jeans

$69.40 $58.99 WILD OAK BOUTIQUE
−20%Jordan Craig Slim Denim Jeans
DTLR-VILLA

Jordan Craig Slim Denim Jeans

$74.98 $59.98 DTLR-VILLA
−39%Preme Studded Stacked Denim Jeans
DTLR-VILLA

Preme Studded Stacked Denim Jeans

$98.33 $59.98 DTLR-VILLA
−30%Lucky Brand Mid Rise Sweet Straight - Women's Pants Denim Straight Leg Jeans
LUCKY BRAND

Lucky Brand Mid Rise Sweet Straight - Women's Pants Denim Straight Leg Jeans

$99.00 $69.30 LUCKY BRAND
Worth the splurge8 pieces
ALIGNE Mid Rise Slim Flare Jeans Jet Black
SHOPBOP

ALIGNE Mid Rise Slim Flare Jeans Jet Black

$145.00 SHOPBOP
PAIGE Federal Transcend Slim Straight Jeans Black Shadow
SHOPBOP

PAIGE Federal Transcend Slim Straight Jeans Black Shadow

$199.00 SHOPBOP
rag & bone Flexi Wren High Rise Ankle Slim Jeans Black
SHOPBOP

rag & bone Flexi Wren High Rise Ankle Slim Jeans Black

$238.00 SHOPBOP
ASKK NY Slim Crop Jeans Black Resin
SHOPBOP

ASKK NY Slim Crop Jeans Black Resin

$220.00 SHOPBOP
Citizens of Humanity Gage Slim Straight Jeans - 32 Raven/Black
SHOPBOP

Citizens of Humanity Gage Slim Straight Jeans - 32 Raven/Black

$198.00 SHOPBOP
PAIGE Lennox Transcend Slim Jeans 32 Black Shadow
SHOPBOP

PAIGE Lennox Transcend Slim Jeans 32 Black Shadow

$199.00 SHOPBOP
GUESS Eco Faye Sailor Flared Jeans
GUESS

GUESS Eco Faye Sailor Flared Jeans

$138.00 GUESS
Jane Jean 28"
ANINE BING

Jane Jean 28"

$250.00 ANINE BING

More like this

See all in Button Fly Jeans →
Button Fly Straight Leg Jeans: Picks We Stand ByButton Fly JeansButton Fly Straight Leg Jeans: Picks We Stand ByWhere to Find the Best Button Fly JeansButton Fly JeansWhere to Find the Best Button Fly JeansOur Top Embroidered Button Fly Denim Jeans Right NowEmbroidered JeansOur Top Embroidered Button Fly Denim Jeans Right NowButton Fly Mom Jeans We’d Happily Wear on RepeatButton Fly JeansButton Fly Mom Jeans We’d Happily Wear on RepeatBlack Button Fly Wide Leg Jeans: Our Top PicksButton Fly JeansBlack Button Fly Wide Leg Jeans: Our Top PicksButton Fly Petite Jeans That Fit ProperlyPetite JeansButton Fly Petite Jeans That Fit Properly