Top Picks
White House Black Market Formal Skirt: Black Argyle Pattern Bottoms - Size
MAGGIE’S PICK THREDUPWhite House Black Market Formal Skirt: Black Argyle Pattern Bottoms - Size
$31.99 THREDUP
ESSENTIEL Womens Black Cotton Blend Pencil Knee Length Skirt Belted
IMOGEN’S PICK CERQULARESSENTIEL Womens Black Cotton Blend Pencil Knee Length Skirt Belted
$19.49 CERQULAR
Women's Stretch Maxi Pencil Skirt - Cotton Blend and No Slits - Black / Medium
TAMSIN’S PICK KOSHER CASUALWomen's Stretch Maxi Pencil Skirt - Cotton Blend and No Slits - Black / Medium
$35.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Leo Jacquard Pencil Skirt - Black/Ivory
ESME’S PICK NATORILeo Jacquard Pencil Skirt - Black/Ivory
$350.00 $70.00 NATORI
Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Black / XXX
HANNAH’S PICK KOSHER CASUALModest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Black / XXX
$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
How we pick

Every collection on Came Saw Wore starts with a pile of products and ends with a short list chosen by real women. For black cotton pencil skirt, that was Maggie, Imogen, Tamsin, Esme and Hannah. They looked at shape, fabric, reviews where there were any and, honestly, whether it made them want to wear it this weekend. Things that look great on a model and terrible on a hanger tend to get cut. The full list underneath is everything that matched, from lots of different shops, so you can still have a proper browse.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $5019 pieces
Faux Knit Denim Knee-Length Pencil Skirt with Stretch - Black / Large
KOSHER CASUAL

Faux Knit Denim Knee-Length Pencil Skirt with Stretch - Black / Large

$28.72 KOSHER CASUAL
Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Classic Modest Fit - Black / Small
KOSHER CASUAL

Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Classic Modest Fit - Black / Small

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
ELLE Contemporary Collection Casual Skirt: Black Houndstooth Pattern Bottoms
THREDUP

ELLE Contemporary Collection Casual Skirt: Black Houndstooth Pattern Bottoms

$15.99 THREDUP
Talbots Casual Skirt: Black Polka Dots Pattern Bottoms - Size 4 Petite
THREDUP

Talbots Casual Skirt: Black Polka Dots Pattern Bottoms - Size 4 Petite

$27.99 THREDUP
Women's Stretch Maxi Pencil Skirt - Cotton Blend and No Slits - Black / Medium
KOSHER CASUAL

Women's Stretch Maxi Pencil Skirt - Cotton Blend and No Slits - Black / Medium

$35.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Onyx Midi Pencil Skirt - 24W UK 4 Black Cotton Blend
CERQULAR

Onyx Midi Pencil Skirt - 24W UK 4 Black Cotton Blend

$10.04 CERQULAR
Trussardi Pencil Skirt - 28W UK 8 Black Cotton
CERQULAR

Trussardi Pencil Skirt - 28W UK 8 Black Cotton

$20.09 CERQULAR
Ann Taylor Casual Skirt: Black Checkered/Gingham Pattern Bottoms - Size 00 Petite
THREDUP

Ann Taylor Casual Skirt: Black Checkered/Gingham Pattern Bottoms - Size 00 Petite

$18.99 THREDUP
Rafaella Formal Skirt: Black Polka Dots Pattern Bottoms - Size
THREDUP

Rafaella Formal Skirt: Black Polka Dots Pattern Bottoms - Size

$8.99 THREDUP
Iceberg Midi Pencil Skirt - 25W UK 6 Black Cotton
CERQULAR

Iceberg Midi Pencil Skirt - 25W UK 6 Black Cotton

$48.02 CERQULAR
White House Black Market Formal Skirt: Black Argyle Pattern Bottoms - Size
THREDUP

White House Black Market Formal Skirt: Black Argyle Pattern Bottoms - Size

$31.99 THREDUP
Talbots Casual Skirt: Black Polka Dots Pattern Bottoms - Size
THREDUP

Talbots Casual Skirt: Black Polka Dots Pattern Bottoms - Size

$23.99 THREDUP
Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Black / Small
KOSHER CASUAL

Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Black / Small

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Black / XXX
KOSHER CASUAL

Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Black / XXX

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
HAMMER Womens Black & White Check Pencil Knee Length Cotton Blend Skirt M Office
CERQULAR

HAMMER Womens Black & White Check Pencil Knee Length Cotton Blend Skirt M Office

$19.49 CERQULAR
ESSENTIEL Womens Black Cotton Blend Pencil Knee Length Skirt Belted
CERQULAR

ESSENTIEL Womens Black Cotton Blend Pencil Knee Length Skirt Belted

$19.49 CERQULAR
ARMANI JEANS Womens Black Pencil Knee Length Cotton Skirt UK 10 Classic Elegant
CERQULAR

ARMANI JEANS Womens Black Pencil Knee Length Cotton Skirt UK 10 Classic Elegant

$33.79 CERQULAR
ESCADA Womens Black Classic Pencil Knee Length Cotton Skirt M Smart Formal
CERQULAR

ESCADA Womens Black Classic Pencil Knee Length Cotton Skirt M Smart Formal

$57.19 CERQULAR
−80%Leo Jacquard Pencil Skirt - Black/Ivory
NATORI

Leo Jacquard Pencil Skirt - Black/Ivory

$350.00 $70.00 NATORI
Worth the splurge6 pieces
POSSE Emma Pencil Skirt Black
SHOPBOP

POSSE Emma Pencil Skirt Black

$320.00 SHOPBOP
Diane Von Furstenberg Black Stretch Cotton Side Zip Detail Noemi Pencil Skirt
THE LUXURY CLOSET

Diane Von Furstenberg Black Stretch Cotton Side Zip Detail Noemi Pencil Skirt

$189.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET
LE BOP Lila Pencil Skirt Black Stripe
SHOPBOP

LE BOP Lila Pencil Skirt Black Stripe

$128.00 SHOPBOP
90s long pencil skirt / Denim like(Blue Black)
W CONCEPT

90s long pencil skirt / Denim like(Blue Black)

$165.00 W CONCEPT
J.Crew Collection Formal Skirt: Black Print Pattern Bottoms - Size
THREDUP

J.Crew Collection Formal Skirt: Black Print Pattern Bottoms - Size

$268.99 THREDUP
Simple Pencil Skirt (2 Colors)
W CONCEPT

Simple Pencil Skirt (2 Colors)

$147.00 W CONCEPT

More like this

See all in Pencil Skirts →
The Blue Knee Length Pencil Skirts on Our WishlistPencil SkirtsThe Blue Knee Length Pencil Skirts on Our WishlistHandpicked Black Leather Pencil Skirts We Keep Coming Back ToPencil SkirtsHandpicked Black Leather Pencil Skirts We Keep Coming Back ToBlue Lace Pencil Skirts Edited Down to the BestPencil SkirtsBlue Lace Pencil Skirts Edited Down to the BestGold Pencil Skirts That Go With EverythingPencil SkirtsGold Pencil Skirts That Go With EverythingShop Our Favorite Belted Pencil SkirtsPencil SkirtsShop Our Favorite Belted Pencil SkirtsShop Our Favorite Black Lace Pencil SkirtsPencil SkirtsShop Our Favorite Black Lace Pencil Skirts