Top Picks

$28.99 THREDUP

$24.99 THREDUP

$48.99 THREDUP
How we pick
These picks came from Lauren, Megan, Chloe, Leanne and Esme, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.
We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money
Under $5011 pieces

THREDUP
J.Crew Casual Dress - Shift: Black Stripes Pattern Dresses - Used - Size X
$14.99 THREDUP
ZEAGOO
Zeagoo Womens Midi Dress Short Sleeve A
$39.07 ZEAGOO
THREDUP
Ann Taylor LOFT Outlet Casual Dress - Shift: Black Argyle Pattern Dresses - Used - Size Medium Petite
$22.99 THREDUP
THREDUP
Style&Co Casual Dress - Shift: Black Graphic Pattern Dresses - Used
$28.99 THREDUP
THREDUP
Maggy London Cocktail Dress - Shift: Black Graphic Pattern Dresses - Used - Size
$39.99 THREDUP
THREDUP
Faded Glory Casual Dress - Shift: Black Floral Pattern Dresses - Used - Size
$14.99 THREDUP
THREDUP
J.Jill Casual Dress - Shift: Black Stripes Pattern Dresses - Used - Size X
$41.99 THREDUP
THREDUP
Parker Casual Dress - Shift: Black Print Pattern Dresses - New - Size X
$33.99 THREDUP
THREDUP
Joe Fresh Casual Dress - Shift: Black Stripes Pattern Dresses - Used
$24.99 THREDUP
ZEAGOO
Vintage Denim Dress Short Sleeve Turn Down Collar Pockets Button Up Shift Summer Long Loose Dress - Black / S(4)
$35.99 ZEAGOO
THREDUP
Talbots Casual Dress - Shift: Black Stripes Pattern Dresses - Used
$48.99 THREDUP$50 to $1009 pieces

RENT THE RUNWAY
Hofmann Copenhagen Josefina Dress Black-multicolored-print
$80.00 RENT THE RUNWAY
RENT THE RUNWAY
Staud Vincent Dress Black
$71.00 RENT THE RUNWAY
UNIQLO
UNIQLO Women's Linen Blend Tiered Dress, Black
$59.90 UNIQLO
RENT THE RUNWAY
By Malene Birger Calynn Dress Black-cream-print
$60.00 RENT THE RUNWAY
CERQULAR
WOOLRICH Womens Blue Denim Shift Cotton Blend Sleeveless Midi XL Pinafore Dress
$58.49 CERQULAR
RENT THE RUNWAY
CeCe Tweed Shift Dress with Patch Pockets Multicolored-black-print
$56.00 RENT THE RUNWAY−84%

NATORI
Nagashi Cotton Chino Shift Dress - White/Black
$406.25 $65.00 NATORI−50%
ANN TAYLOR
Ann Taylor Tweed Button Shift Dress
$179.98 $89.99 ANN TAYLOR−80%

NATORI
Leo Jacquard Dress
$450.00 $90.00 NATORIWorth the splurge5 pieces

THREDUP
Milly Casual Dress - Shift: Black Print Pattern Dresses - Used - Size
$196.99 THREDUP
RENT THE RUNWAY
MM6 Maison Margiela Sweater Mini Dress Black
$229.00 RENT THE RUNWAYANTHROPOLOGIE
Cotton Printed Shift Dress
$148.00 ANTHROPOLOGIE
THE LUXURY CLOSET
See by Chloe Black Cotton Knit & Silk Shift Dress
$162.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET−70%

NATORI
Yantra Funnel Shift Dress
$496.67 $149.00 NATORIMore like this
See all in Shift Dresses →
Knee Length DressesBlue Knee Length Shift Dresses You’ll Want to Live In
Shift DressesBlack Jersey Shift Dresses You’ll Want to Live In
Shift DressesBlack Sleeveless Shift Dresses: Picks We Stand By
Shift DressesBlue Mini Shift Dresses: Picks We Stand By
Shift DressesBlue Short Sleeve Shift Dresses Worth a Closer Look
Shift DressesCotton Sleeveless Shift Dresses: Our Top Picks







