Top Picks
Goddiva Puff Sleeve Sweetheart Midi Dress
IMOGEN’S PICK GODDIVAGoddiva Puff Sleeve Sweetheart Midi Dress
$135.00 GODDIVA
Allure At Dusk Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black
LAUREN’S PICK HELLO MOLLYAllure At Dusk Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black
$85.00 HELLO MOLLY
Flora Botanica Midi Dress Black
MAGGIE’S PICK HELLO MOLLYFlora Botanica Midi Dress Black
$99.95 HELLO MOLLY
Xenia Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black
LEANNE’S PICK HELLO MOLLYXenia Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black
$95.95 HELLO MOLLY
Plum Temptation Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black
ESME’S PICK HELLOMOLLYPlum Temptation Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black
$119.95 HELLOMOLLY
How we pick

These picks came from Imogen, Lauren, Maggie, Leanne and Esme, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $503 pieces
Lulus Casual Dress: Black Floral Pattern Dresses
THREDUP

Lulus Casual Dress: Black Floral Pattern Dresses

$23.99 THREDUP
Lulus Casual Dress: Black Floral Pattern Dresses - Used
THREDUP

Lulus Casual Dress: Black Floral Pattern Dresses - Used

$23.99 THREDUP
Amuse Society Casual Dress: Black Dresses
THREDUP

Amuse Society Casual Dress: Black Dresses

$9.99 THREDUP
$50 to $1009 pieces
Goddiva Bardot Sequin & Lace High Low Midi
GODDIVA

Goddiva Bardot Sequin & Lace High Low Midi

$85.00 GODDIVA
Goddiva Scuba & Polka Mesh Off The Shoulder Midi Dress
GODDIVA

Goddiva Scuba & Polka Mesh Off The Shoulder Midi Dress

$85.00 GODDIVA
Beverly Hills One Shoulder Midi Dress Black
HELLO MOLLY

Beverly Hills One Shoulder Midi Dress Black

$89.00 HELLO MOLLY
Flora Botanica Midi Dress Black
HELLO MOLLY

Flora Botanica Midi Dress Black

$99.95 HELLO MOLLY
Xenia Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black
HELLO MOLLY

Xenia Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black

$95.95 HELLO MOLLY
Allure At Dusk Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black
HELLO MOLLY

Allure At Dusk Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black

$85.00 HELLO MOLLY
Goddiva Corset Fit & Flare Midi Dress
GODDIVA

Goddiva Corset Fit & Flare Midi Dress

$85.00 GODDIVA
Goddiva Glitter Velvet Cowl Neck Sheath Midi Dress
GODDIVA

Goddiva Glitter Velvet Cowl Neck Sheath Midi Dress

$65.00 GODDIVA
Goddiva Diagonal Stripe Velvet Bow A Line Midi Dress
GODDIVA

Goddiva Diagonal Stripe Velvet Bow A Line Midi Dress

$75.00 GODDIVA
Worth the splurge13 pieces
Black Halo Jacqueline Midi Dress Porcelain
SHOPBOP

Black Halo Jacqueline Midi Dress Porcelain

$390.00 SHOPBOP
Ramy Brook Stripe Chet Dress Black Stripe
SHOPBOP

Ramy Brook Stripe Chet Dress Black Stripe

$365.00 SHOPBOP
Black Halo Jacqueline Midi Dress Pacific Blue
SHOPBOP

Black Halo Jacqueline Midi Dress Pacific Blue

$390.00 SHOPBOP
HELLO MOLLY Midnight Memories Midi Dress Black
HELLO MOLLY

HELLO MOLLY Midnight Memories Midi Dress Black

$137.38 HELLO MOLLY
Roberto Cavalli Black Knit Off Shoulder Midi Dress
THE LUXURY CLOSET

Roberto Cavalli Black Knit Off Shoulder Midi Dress

$250.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET
Goddiva Puff Sleeve Sweetheart Midi Dress
GODDIVA

Goddiva Puff Sleeve Sweetheart Midi Dress

$135.00 GODDIVA
Hudson Off Shoulder Midi Dress
PETAL & PUP

Hudson Off Shoulder Midi Dress

$100.00 PETAL & PUP
The Wolf Gang Amar Midi Dress Black
RENT THE RUNWAY

The Wolf Gang Amar Midi Dress Black

$281.00 RENT THE RUNWAY
Self-Portrait Black Stretch Crepe Crystal Off-Shoulder Midi Dress
THE LUXURY CLOSET

Self-Portrait Black Stretch Crepe Crystal Off-Shoulder Midi Dress

$188.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET
Editorial Mood Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black
HELLO MOLLY

Editorial Mood Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black

$109.95 HELLO MOLLY
Plum Temptation Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black
HELLOMOLLY

Plum Temptation Off Shoulder Midi Dress Black

$119.95 HELLOMOLLY
The Hype Off Shoulder Satin Midi Dress Black
HELLOMOLLY

The Hype Off Shoulder Satin Midi Dress Black

$109.95 HELLOMOLLY
−40%LE BOP Gingham Knit Off Shoulder Dress Chocolate/Black
SHOPBOP

LE BOP Gingham Knit Off Shoulder Dress Chocolate/Black

$298.00 $178.80 SHOPBOP

More like this

See all in Off Shoulder Dresses →
Black Casual Off Shoulder Dresses We’ve Been SavingCasual DressesBlack Casual Off Shoulder Dresses We’ve Been SavingThe Only Blue Off Shoulder Floral Dresses You Need to SeeOff Shoulder DressesThe Only Blue Off Shoulder Floral Dresses You Need to SeeBirthday Off Shoulder Dresses You’ll Reach for FirstOff Shoulder DressesBirthday Off Shoulder Dresses You’ll Reach for FirstBlack Floral Off Shoulder Dresses: What We’d Buy NowOff Shoulder DressesBlack Floral Off Shoulder Dresses: What We’d Buy NowThe Best Burgundy Off Shoulder Mini Dresses to Shop NowBurgundy DressesThe Best Burgundy Off Shoulder Mini Dresses to Shop NowThe Black Off Shoulder Lace Dresses We’d Wear AnywhereOff Shoulder DressesThe Black Off Shoulder Lace Dresses We’d Wear Anywhere