Top Picks
Nova Mary Janes - Black - 35EU / 3.5US
TAMSIN’S PICK MERI MERINova Mary Janes - Black - 35EU / 3.5US
$68.00 MERI MERI
Chocolaticas® Melancholy - Gothic Rose & Lace Mid Heels
ESME’S PICK CRONJAGERChocolaticas® Melancholy - Gothic Rose & Lace Mid Heels
$121.00 CRONJAGER
TinaCus Women's Pointed Toe Genuine Leather Handmade Slip On Buckle Mid Chunky Heel Mary Janes - Black / US5.5/CN35/EU36/UK3.5/Foot Length-22.5cm
AISHA’S PICK TINACUSTOMTinaCus Women's Pointed Toe Genuine Leather Handmade Slip On Buckle Mid Chunky Heel Mary Janes - Black / US5.5/CN35/EU36/UK3.5/Foot Length-22.5cm
$102.40 TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Round Toe Slip-on Chunky Heel Mary Jane Shoes with Bowknot - Black / US7.5/CN38/EU38/UK5.5/Foot Length-24cm
ELLIE’S PICK TINACUSTOMTinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Round Toe Slip-on Chunky Heel Mary Jane Shoes with Bowknot - Black / US7.5/CN38/EU38/UK5.5/Foot Length-24cm
$106.40 TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Mary Janes for Women with Double Straps Buckle - Black / US7/CN37/EU37/UK4.5-5/Foot Length-23.5cm
CHLOE’S PICK TINACUSTOMTinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Mary Janes for Women with Double Straps Buckle - Black / US7/CN37/EU37/UK4.5-5/Foot Length-23.5cm
$99.40 TINACUSTOM
How we pick

Quick word on how this list was made. Tamsin, Esme, Aisha, Ellie and Chloe picked their favourites from the black rubber mary janes we found across loads of UK shops. No sponsored spots, no brand deals, just what they'd buy with their own money. We keep a mix of prices so there's something whether you're treating yourself or being sensible this month, and we limit how many come from one retailer. Stock and prices update regularly from each shop, so if something's gone, it's sold out rather than hidden.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

$50 to $1007 pieces
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather T-Strap Buckle Square Toe High Block Heel Mary Janes Pumps Shoes - US6/CN36/EU36/UK4/Foot Length-23cm / brown
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather T-Strap Buckle Square Toe High Block Heel Mary Janes Pumps Shoes - US6/CN36/EU36/UK4/Foot Length-23cm / brown

$94.70 TINACUSTOM
Women Samba Jane Cloud White/Alumina/Core Black Sneakers 10 Cloud White/Alumina/Core Black
SHIEKH

Women Samba Jane Cloud White/Alumina/Core Black Sneakers 10 Cloud White/Alumina/Core Black

$99.99 SHIEKH
Missy Mary Janes - Gold - 31EU / 13.5US
MERI MERI

Missy Mary Janes - Gold - 31EU / 13.5US

$74.00 MERI MERI
Nova Mary Janes - Black - 35EU / 3.5US
MERI MERI

Nova Mary Janes - Black - 35EU / 3.5US

$68.00 MERI MERI
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Mary Janes for Women with Double Straps Buckle - Black / US7/CN37/EU37/UK4.5-5/Foot Length-23.5cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Mary Janes for Women with Double Straps Buckle - Black / US7/CN37/EU37/UK4.5-5/Foot Length-23.5cm

$99.40 TINACUSTOM
Chocolaticas® Spectral Ride - Gothic Carousel Mary Jane Flats - Size UK 8.5 Left Only!
CRONJAGER

Chocolaticas® Spectral Ride - Gothic Carousel Mary Jane Flats - Size UK 8.5 Left Only!

$82.00 CRONJAGER
Bailey Ribbon Mary Jane Shoes
W CONCEPT

Bailey Ribbon Mary Jane Shoes

$66.00 W CONCEPT
Worth the splurge8 pieces
Preakness Split-Toe Mary Janes
ANTHROPOLOGIE

Preakness Split-Toe Mary Janes

$170.00 ANTHROPOLOGIE
rag & bone Spire Mary Janes Black 39.5
SHOPBOP

rag & bone Spire Mary Janes Black 39.5

$298.00 SHOPBOP
Tory Burch Romy Mary Janes Perfect Black
SHOPBOP

Tory Burch Romy Mary Janes Perfect Black

$250.00 SHOPBOP
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Round Toe Braided T-Strap Stacked Heel Pump Shoes - brown / US8.5/CN40/EU39/UK6.5/Foot Length-25cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Round Toe Braided T-Strap Stacked Heel Pump Shoes - brown / US8.5/CN40/EU39/UK6.5/Foot Length-25cm

$104.00 TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Women's Pointed Toe Genuine Leather Handmade Slip On Buckle Mid Chunky Heel Mary Janes - Black / US5.5/CN35/EU36/UK3.5/Foot Length-22.5cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Women's Pointed Toe Genuine Leather Handmade Slip On Buckle Mid Chunky Heel Mary Janes - Black / US5.5/CN35/EU36/UK3.5/Foot Length-22.5cm

$102.40 TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Buckle Strap Round Toe Mary Jane Flats Shoes - Black / US5.5/CN35/EU36/UK3.5/Foot Length-22.5cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Buckle Strap Round Toe Mary Jane Flats Shoes - Black / US5.5/CN35/EU36/UK3.5/Foot Length-22.5cm

$103.00 TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Round Toe Slip-on Chunky Heel Mary Jane Shoes with Bowknot - Black / US7.5/CN38/EU38/UK5.5/Foot Length-24cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Round Toe Slip-on Chunky Heel Mary Jane Shoes with Bowknot - Black / US7.5/CN38/EU38/UK5.5/Foot Length-24cm

$106.40 TINACUSTOM
Chocolaticas® Melancholy - Gothic Rose & Lace Mid Heels
CRONJAGER

Chocolaticas® Melancholy - Gothic Rose & Lace Mid Heels

$121.00 CRONJAGER

More like this

See all in Black Shoes →
Black Kitten Heel Shoes: Our Honest ShortlistBlack ShoesBlack Kitten Heel Shoes: Our Honest ShortlistBlack Snake Shoes We Love Right NowBlack ShoesBlack Snake Shoes We Love Right NowBlack Patent Shoes That Earn Their PlaceBlack ShoesBlack Patent Shoes That Earn Their PlaceBlack High Espadrilles We’d Recommend to a FriendEspadrillesBlack High Espadrilles We’d Recommend to a FriendThe Black Cut Out Pumps ShortlistBlack ShoesThe Black Cut Out Pumps ShortlistBlack Platform Wedges We Love Right NowWedgesBlack Platform Wedges We Love Right Now