Top Picks
Women Object-S Green Plaid/Red/Black Shoes 6.5 Green Plaid/Red/Black
HANNAH’S PICK SHIEKHWomen Object-S Green Plaid/Red/Black Shoes 6.5 Green Plaid/Red/Black
$39.96 $9.99 SHIEKH
TinaCus Women’s Square Toe Low Block Heel Slip On Loafers - Black / US8/CN39/EU39/UK6/Foot Length-24.5cm
MEGAN’S PICK TINACUSTOMTinaCus Women’s Square Toe Low Block Heel Slip On Loafers - Black / US8/CN39/EU39/UK6/Foot Length-24.5cm
$109.50 TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Braided Chunky Heel Casual Slip On Ballet Shoes - Black / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
MAGGIE’S PICK TINACUSTOMTinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Braided Chunky Heel Casual Slip On Ballet Shoes - Black / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
$104.00 TINACUSTOM
Reebok Work Soyay Slip Resistant Steel Toe Work Shoes
ZARA’S PICK SHOEBACCAReebok Work Soyay Slip Resistant Steel Toe Work Shoes
$99.95 SHOEBACCA
Leather Fur Slip-On Shoes [Black]
DANI’S PICK W CONCEPTLeather Fur Slip-On Shoes [Black]
$194.00 W CONCEPT
How we pick

These picks came from Hannah, Megan, Maggie, Zara and Dani, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $506 pieces
Coldwater Creek Flats: Black Houndstooth Pattern Shoes
THREDUP

Coldwater Creek Flats: Black Houndstooth Pattern Shoes

$30.99 THREDUP
Mix No. 6 Sneakers: Black Animal Print Pattern Shoes - Size
THREDUP

Mix No. 6 Sneakers: Black Animal Print Pattern Shoes - Size

$28.99 THREDUP
Pace - Wide Toe Shoes - Black / EU
HOBIBEAR

Pace - Wide Toe Shoes - Black / EU

$49.99 HOBIBEAR
−94%Women Phantom-01 Black Shoes 6.5 Black
SHIEKH

Women Phantom-01 Black Shoes 6.5 Black

$33.17 $1.99 SHIEKH
−93%Women Object-GS Black Glitter Black Glitter Shoes 5.5 Black Glitter
SHIEKH

Women Object-GS Black Glitter Black Glitter Shoes 5.5 Black Glitter

$28.43 $1.99 SHIEKH
−75%Women Object-S Green Plaid/Red/Black Shoes 6.5 Green Plaid/Red/Black
SHIEKH

Women Object-S Green Plaid/Red/Black Shoes 6.5 Green Plaid/Red/Black

$39.96 $9.99 SHIEKH
$50 to $1003 pieces
TinaCus Women's Genuine Leather Handmade Cap-Toe Spool Heel Slip On Loafer Pumps Shoes - US8.5/CN40/EU39/UK6.5/Foot Length-25cm / green
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Women's Genuine Leather Handmade Cap-Toe Spool Heel Slip On Loafer Pumps Shoes - US8.5/CN40/EU39/UK6.5/Foot Length-25cm / green

$88.50 TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Round Toe Slip On Flat Shoes - black / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Round Toe Slip On Flat Shoes - black / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm

$98.00 TINACUSTOM
Reebok Work Soyay Slip Resistant Steel Toe Work Shoes
SHOEBACCA

Reebok Work Soyay Slip Resistant Steel Toe Work Shoes

$99.95 SHOEBACCA
Worth the splurge7 pieces
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Classic Slip On V-Cut Round Toe Loafer Flats Shoes - brown / US5.5/CN35/EU36/UK3.5/Foot Length-22.5cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Classic Slip On V-Cut Round Toe Loafer Flats Shoes - brown / US5.5/CN35/EU36/UK3.5/Foot Length-22.5cm

$104.70 TINACUSTOM
Allen Edmonds James Patent Leather Slip On Tuxedo Shoes Black 001 8.5
SHOPBOP

Allen Edmonds James Patent Leather Slip On Tuxedo Shoes Black 001 8.5

$450.00 SHOPBOP
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Braided Chunky Heel Casual Slip On Ballet Shoes - Black / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Braided Chunky Heel Casual Slip On Ballet Shoes - Black / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm

$104.00 TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Women’s Square Toe Low Block Heel Slip On Loafers - Black / US8/CN39/EU39/UK6/Foot Length-24.5cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Women’s Square Toe Low Block Heel Slip On Loafers - Black / US8/CN39/EU39/UK6/Foot Length-24.5cm

$109.50 TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Woven Chunky Heel Slip-On Office Loafer Shoes - Black / US7/CN37/EU37/UK4.5-5/Foot Length-23.5cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Woven Chunky Heel Slip-On Office Loafer Shoes - Black / US7/CN37/EU37/UK4.5-5/Foot Length-23.5cm

$104.00 TINACUSTOM
Leather Fur Slip-On Shoes [Black]
W CONCEPT

Leather Fur Slip-On Shoes [Black]

$194.00 W CONCEPT
Nike Women's Vomero 18 Running Shoes (Extra Wide Width) in Black/Coconut Milk/Light Iron Ore Size: 5.0
JD SPORTS

Nike Women's Vomero 18 Running Shoes (Extra Wide Width) in Black/Coconut Milk/Light Iron Ore Size: 5.0

$155.00 JD SPORTS

More like this

See all in Black Shoes →
Black Comfort Pumps That Go With EverythingBlack ShoesBlack Comfort Pumps That Go With EverythingBlack Ankle Strap Espadrilles That Tick Every BoxEspadrillesBlack Ankle Strap Espadrilles That Tick Every BoxBlack Quilted Shoes We Love Right NowBlack ShoesBlack Quilted Shoes We Love Right NowThe Black Woven Espadrilles Your Shoe Rack NeedsEspadrillesThe Black Woven Espadrilles Your Shoe Rack NeedsBlack Pointed Slingbacks: Our Top PicksBlack ShoesBlack Pointed Slingbacks: Our Top PicksBlack Patent Shoes That Earn Their PlaceBlack ShoesBlack Patent Shoes That Earn Their Place