Top Picks
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Mary Janes for Women with Double Straps Buckle - Black / US7/CN37/EU37/UK4.5-5/Foot Length-23.5cm
FREYA’S PICK TINACUSTOMTinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Mary Janes for Women with Double Straps Buckle - Black / US7/CN37/EU37/UK4.5-5/Foot Length-23.5cm
$99.40 TINACUSTOM
Square-Toe Leather Mary Jane Shoes [Black]
ELLIE’S PICK W CONCEPTSquare-Toe Leather Mary Jane Shoes [Black]
$220.00 W CONCEPT
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather T-Strap Buckle Square Toe High Block Heel Mary Janes Pumps Shoes - US6/CN36/EU36/UK4/Foot Length-23cm / brown
ESME’S PICK TINACUSTOMTinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather T-Strap Buckle Square Toe High Block Heel Mary Janes Pumps Shoes - US6/CN36/EU36/UK4/Foot Length-23cm / brown
$94.70 TINACUSTOM
Square-Toe Leather Mary Jane Shoes [Silver]
DANI’S PICK W CONCEPTSquare-Toe Leather Mary Jane Shoes [Silver]
$220.00 W CONCEPT
rag & bone Spire Mary Janes Black 39.5
NADIA’S PICK SHOPBOPrag & bone Spire Mary Janes Black 39.5
$298.00 SHOPBOP
How we pick

Quick word on how this list was made. Freya, Ellie, Esme, Dani and Nadia picked their favourites from the black square toe mary janes we found across loads of UK shops. No sponsored spots, no brand deals, just what they'd buy with their own money. We keep a mix of prices so there's something whether you're treating yourself or being sensible this month, and we limit how many come from one retailer. Stock and prices update regularly from each shop, so if something's gone, it's sold out rather than hidden.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

More like this

See all in Black Shoes →
Our Shortlist of Black Flat PumpsBlack ShoesOur Shortlist of Black Flat PumpsBlack Woven Shoes You’ll Actually Want to Walk InBlack ShoesBlack Woven Shoes You’ll Actually Want to Walk InComfortable Black Square Toe Shoes That Still Look GoodBlack ShoesComfortable Black Square Toe Shoes That Still Look GoodOur Pick of the Best Black Boat ShoesBlack ShoesOur Pick of the Best Black Boat ShoesBlack Slip On Pumps That Tick Every BoxBlack ShoesBlack Slip On Pumps That Tick Every BoxBlack Chunky Mary Janes With Real Wardrobe Staying PowerBlack ShoesBlack Chunky Mary Janes With Real Wardrobe Staying Power