Top Picks
BOSS Tevan Loafers Dark Brown
LEANNE’S PICK SHOPBOPBOSS Tevan Loafers Dark Brown
$230.00 SHOPBOP
Sperry Authentic Original Leather Venetian Loafers Other Brown
ELLIE’S PICK SHOPBOPSperry Authentic Original Leather Venetian Loafers Other Brown
$130.00 SHOPBOP
Sebago Portland Artisan Adirondak Loafers Brown 10.5
FIONA’S PICK SHOPBOPSebago Portland Artisan Adirondak Loafers Brown 10.5
$215.00 SHOPBOP
TORY BURCH 'Sport Ballet' Brown Suede Loafers
ESME’S PICK VALICOTORY BURCH 'Sport Ballet' Brown Suede Loafers
$356.00 VALICO
Gucci Brown Diamante Leather Leather Penny Slip On Loafers
CHLOE’S PICK THE LUXURY CLOSETGucci Brown Diamante Leather Leather Penny Slip On Loafers
$343.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET
How we pick

These picks came from Leanne, Ellie, Fiona, Esme and Chloe, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

$50 to $1004 pieces
Worth the splurge21 pieces
PARABOOT 'Barth' Brown Leather Loafers
VALICO

PARABOOT 'Barth' Brown Leather Loafers

$286.00 VALICO
Sperry Authentic Original Leather Venetian Loafers Other Brown
SHOPBOP

Sperry Authentic Original Leather Venetian Loafers Other Brown

$130.00 SHOPBOP
TinaCus Women's Square Toe Genuine Leather Handmade Low Heels Casual Loafers Shoes - brown / US4.5/CN33/EU34/UK2-2.5/Foot Length-21.5cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Women's Square Toe Genuine Leather Handmade Low Heels Casual Loafers Shoes - brown / US4.5/CN33/EU34/UK2-2.5/Foot Length-21.5cm

$106.00 TINACUSTOM
Vince Hann Loafers Cocoa Brown 9.5
SHOPBOP

Vince Hann Loafers Cocoa Brown 9.5

$295.00 SHOPBOP
Tod's Brown Suede Gommini Driver Loafers
THE LUXURY CLOSET

Tod's Brown Suede Gommini Driver Loafers

$163.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET
TinaCus Women's Genuine Leather Mary Jane Shoes Handmade Square Toe T-Strap Buckle Loafers - Black / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Women's Genuine Leather Mary Jane Shoes Handmade Square Toe T-Strap Buckle Loafers - Black / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm

$113.00 TINACUSTOM
BOSS Tevan Loafers Dark Brown
SHOPBOP

BOSS Tevan Loafers Dark Brown

$230.00 SHOPBOP
Vinny's Martel Embossed Loafers Brown Crocco
SHOPBOP

Vinny's Martel Embossed Loafers Brown Crocco

$390.00 SHOPBOP
Vince Grant Suede Loafers Cocoa Brown
SHOPBOP

Vince Grant Suede Loafers Cocoa Brown

$350.00 SHOPBOP
TinaCus Handmade Women's Penny Loafers Round Toe Genuine Leather Ruched Slip-on Shoes Comfortable Office - Beige / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Handmade Women's Penny Loafers Round Toe Genuine Leather Ruched Slip-on Shoes Comfortable Office - Beige / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm

$103.00 TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Women's Handmade Geniuine Leather Slip on Closed Toe Classic Office Loafer Shoes - brown / US4.5/CN33/EU34/UK2-2.5/Foot Length-21.5cm
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Women's Handmade Geniuine Leather Slip on Closed Toe Classic Office Loafer Shoes - brown / US4.5/CN33/EU34/UK2-2.5/Foot Length-21.5cm

$105.40 TINACUSTOM
Sebago Portland Artisan Adirondak Loafers Brown 10.5
SHOPBOP

Sebago Portland Artisan Adirondak Loafers Brown 10.5

$215.00 SHOPBOP
Cashmere Loafers in Golden Brown - 39 / Golden Brown / UF0004-0927
GOBI CASHMERE

Cashmere Loafers in Golden Brown - 39 / Golden Brown / UF0004-0927

$219.00 GOBI CASHMERE
Tod's Brown Suede Penny Loafers
THE LUXURY CLOSET

Tod's Brown Suede Penny Loafers

$163.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET
Cole Haan Women's Pinch Long-Weekender Penny Loafers - Brown Size
COLE HAAN

Cole Haan Women's Pinch Long-Weekender Penny Loafers - Brown Size

$135.00 COLE HAAN
T003 Banding Loafer Dark Brown (1cm)
W CONCEPT

T003 Banding Loafer Dark Brown (1cm)

$180.00 W CONCEPT
Tod's Brown Leather Bow Slip On Loafers
THE LUXURY CLOSET

Tod's Brown Leather Bow Slip On Loafers

$159.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET
TORY BURCH 'Sport Ballet' Brown Suede Loafers
VALICO

TORY BURCH 'Sport Ballet' Brown Suede Loafers

$356.00 VALICO
Weejuns Whitney Loafers
ANTHROPOLOGIE

Weejuns Whitney Loafers

$175.00 ANTHROPOLOGIE
Gucci Brown Diamante Leather Leather Penny Slip On Loafers
THE LUXURY CLOSET

Gucci Brown Diamante Leather Leather Penny Slip On Loafers

$343.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET
−19%Cole Haan Women's Treena Lug Loafers - Brown Size
COLE HAAN

Cole Haan Women's Treena Lug Loafers - Brown Size

$160.43 $129.95 COLE HAAN