My first long sleeve top came from a multipack of three, all slightly different necklines, all the same thin grey jersey that had gone bobbled under the arms by the second wash. It taught me that a long sleeve top lives or dies on what happens to the cuffs and the underarm seam after a week of actual wearing, not on how it looks folded on a shelf.
A good one has some weight to the fabric, enough that it skims rather than clings, and a cuff that keeps its shape instead of stretching out into a loose flap by lunchtime. Check the seam under the arm, that's where a cheap one gives up first, puckering or splitting a little more each wash. The better ones use a fabric with a bit of stretch recovery, so it comes back to shape rather than bagging at the elbows after you've sat at a desk in it all day. Necklines matter more than you'd think too, a slightly too wide scoop will slip and need adjusting every ten minutes, which gets tiresome fast. Look at the finish on the hem as well, a proper double stitch rather than a single line that starts unravelling the first time it catches on a zip.
Where it struggles is in real heat. A long sleeve top in anything but the lightest cotton or a proper linen blend is a misery from about May onwards, and I've sweated through enough of them on warm trains to know pushing the sleeves up doesn't fix it, it just gives you a top with permanently crumpled arms. It's also not the top for anything that needs real structure, if you want something that holds a shape through a long day of standing or presenting, a jersey long sleeve will let you down by the afternoon, going soft and a bit shapeless exactly where you need it not to. Midwinter it needs help too, on its own it's not enough against proper cold, it wants a coat or at least a decent jumper over the top rather than standing alone.
It clashes badly with anything else fitted and clingy on top, two close fitting layers together just look like you're wearing underwear as outerwear by accident. I'd also think twice about pairing a very thin jersey one with heavy, stiff trousers, the mix of a soft floaty top and something rigid below tends to look like you got dressed from two different outfits. On a cool spring morning with a bit of looseness to the trousers and nothing competing for attention, it works without trying.
Would I still want this top in three months when the weather's changed, or is it only doing a job for me right now, this week, in this exact temperature?
Our Edit of the Best Tie Dye Long Sleeve Tops
Easy Tie Front Long Sleeve Tops for Everyday Wear
Square Neck Long Sleeve Tops We Can’t Stop Looking At
The Slim Fit Long Sleeve Tops Worth Your Wardrobe Space
Silver Long Sleeve Tops Worth Layering
Silk Long Sleeve Tops to Wear With Your Favorite Jeans
Sheer TopsThe Best Sheer Long Sleeve Tops to Shop Now
Scoop Neck Long Sleeve Tops We Love Right Now
Satin TopsSatin Long Sleeve Tops We’re Adding to BasketAlso worth a lookShirtsA good shirt sits flat across the back and skims the chest without pulling at the buttons, so from across a room it reads crisp rather than strained.See the collections →
Ruffle Long Sleeve Tops: Our Top Picks
Our Edit of the Best Ruched Long Sleeve Tops
Ribbed TopsRibbed Long Sleeve Tops Edited Down to the Best
Red TopsRed Ribbed Long Sleeve Tops We Think You’ll Love
Red TopsRed Long Sleeve Ribbed Tops That Go With Everything
Red TopsRed Long Sleeve Tops: The Ones Worth Your Money
Red TopsThe Best Red Cotton Long Sleeve Tops to Shop Now
Easy Purple Long Sleeve Tops for Everyday Wear
Printed Long Sleeve Tops That Work Hard in Your WardrobeAlso worth a lookT-ShirtsThe one I reach for is the one already on the chair from yesterday, not folded, just there,…See the collections →
Shop the Edit: Polka Dot Long Sleeve Tops
Curve Friendly Picks: Plus Size Long Sleeve Tops
Pink TopsPink Long Sleeve Ribbed Tops That Make Outfits Feel New
Pink TopsPink Long Sleeve Tops We Can’t Stop Looking At
Denim TopsPink Denim Long Sleeve Tops That Earn Their Place
Pink TopsPink Cotton Long Sleeve Tops Worth Adding to Your Wardrobe
Peplum TopsPeplum Long Sleeve Tops: Picks We Stand By
Our Pick of the Best Party Long Sleeve Tops
The Oversized Long Sleeve Tops We Keep Going Back ToAlso worth a lookBlack TopsA black top is the thing you reach for when you need to look like you've made an effort without actually making one.See the collections →
Everyday Orange Long Sleeve Tops We Love
Cotton TopsOur Kind of Orange Cotton Long Sleeve Tops
One Shoulder Long Sleeve Tops: What We’d Buy Now
Our Shortlist of Off Shoulder Long Sleeve Tops
Navy TopsNavy Ribbed Long Sleeve Tops We Think You’ll Love
Navy TopsNavy Long Sleeve Tops Worth Layering
Navy TopsNavy Cotton Long Sleeve Tops to Wear With Your Favorite Jeans
Mesh TopsEveryday Mesh Long Sleeve Tops We Love
