The first thing I do with a zip hoodie is run the zip up and down twice before I even look at the price. If it catches on the fabric at the bottom or feels gritty going up, that is how it behaves forever, not just in the shop. A good zip glides with almost no resistance and has a bit of weight to the pull, something you can grab with cold fingers or half asleep, not a thin little tab that snaps off by March.
Past that, it is about what the zip is attached to. Thinner hoodies with a flimsy zip sewn into stretchy cotton will pucker along the seam within a few washes, so the front goes slightly wavy and never sits flat again. Look for a tape that is stitched down properly on both sides, not just caught in a single line of thread, and a fabric with enough body that it does not pull away from the zip when you move. The inside tells you more than the outside. A brushed, slightly fluffy lining that still feels soft after a wash is the sign of a decent one. If the inside feels thin and slightly plasticky even new, it will go bobbly and flat fast. Metal zips tend to outlast plastic ones, but only if the fabric around them is substantial enough to hold them without fraying, so check both together rather than judging the hardware on its own.
Colour wise, I have learned to stop buying anything too pale if it is getting proper wear, because the zip area and cuffs show grime first and a light grey or white hoodie front looks grubby long before the rest does. A mid grey, a soft navy or a plain black hides that and still looks easy with almost everything, jeans, leggings, a skirt even, which I did not expect the first time I tried it. Bright colours are lovely for a season but they fade unevenly round a zip, so I keep those for the ones I am not relying on long term.
If someone has none of these at all, I would start with a mid grey or navy one in a slightly heavier fabric than feels necessary in the shop, because it will stretch and soften with wear rather than thin out. Skip the oversized novelty prints for the first one and get the plain, well made version, it will get worn more than any of the fun ones.
So before I buy, I ask myself one thing: if I run this zip up and down fifty times this month, not once, is it still going to feel this easy?
Cropped HoodiesGreen Cropped Zip Hoodies We’d Recommend to a Friend
Cotton HoodiesA Closer Look at the Best Green Cotton Zip Hoodies
Green Brushed Zip Hoodies That Feel Special
Graphic Zip Hoodies: Our Top Picks
Relaxed HoodiesFinding the Best Gold Relaxed Zip Hoodies
Gold Hooded Zip Hoodies We’d Buy Again
The Best Looking Gold Embroidered Zip Hoodies Out There
Cotton HoodiesEasy Gold Cotton Zip Hoodies for Everyday Wear
Fleece HoodiesOur Favorite Fleece Washed Zip HoodiesAlso worth a lookOversized HoodiesFor years I bought my hoodies one size up and called that oversized, then wondered why I looked…See the collections →
Fleece HoodiesFleece Zip Hoodies We Love Right Now
Fleece HoodiesCosy Fleece Cropped Zip Hoodies We Love
Fleece HoodiesFleece Embroidered Zip Hoodies That Make Outfits Feel New
Fleece HoodiesFleece Graphic Zip Hoodies We’d Happily Wear on Repeat
Fleece HoodiesFleece Half Zip Hoodies We’d Buy Again
Fleece HoodiesFleece Hooded Zip Hoodies With Real Wardrobe Staying Power
Fleece HoodiesFleece Oversized Zip Hoodies for Colder Days
Fleece HoodiesEveryday Fleece Relaxed Zip Hoodies We Love
Shop the Edit: Embroidered Zip HoodiesAlso worth a lookCotton HoodiesFor years I thought a cotton hoodie was the colour equivalent of giving up, the thing you wore…See the collections →
Cropped HoodiesOur Top Cropped Zip Hoodies Right Now
Cream Zip Hoodies That Make Outfits Feel New
Oversized HoodiesCream Oversized Zip Hoodies: Our Current Favorites
Relaxed HoodiesEveryday Cream Relaxed Zip Hoodies We Love
Everyday Cream Hooded Zip Hoodies We Love
Cropped HoodiesThe Best Looking Cream Cropped Zip Hoodies Out There
Cream Embroidered Zip Hoodies: Our Honest Shortlist
Cotton HoodiesCotton Zip Hoodies to Wear With Your Favorite Jeans
Cotton HoodiesCotton Slogan Zip Hoodies We’re Adding to BasketAlso worth a lookCropped HoodiesMy first cropped hoodie came from a supermarket clothing rail, bought in a hurry for a weekend away,…See the collections →
Cotton HoodiesA Closer Look at the Best Cotton Washed Zip Hoodies
Relaxed HoodiesCotton Relaxed Zip Hoodies With Real Wardrobe Staying Power
Cotton HoodiesCotton Oversized Zip Hoodies We Think You’ll Love
Cotton HoodiesCotton Graphic Zip Hoodies We’d Happily Wear on Repeat
Cotton HoodiesCotton Half Zip Hoodies: Our Honest Shortlist
Cotton HoodiesA Closer Look at the Best Cotton Hooded Zip Hoodies
Cotton HoodiesThe Cotton Boxy Zip Hoodies Worth Your Wardrobe Space
Cropped HoodiesCotton Cropped Zip Hoodies That Make Outfits Feel New
