Lace up boots have a reputation for being the boot you buy when you want to look like you mean business, and most of the time that reputation holds. I land somewhere sensible on them: brilliant when the leather and the eyelets are proper, a slow disappointment when they're not. The cheap version looks identical in a photo and completely different after three weeks, the laces fraying at the tips, the eyelets going dull and slightly bent, the sole starting to peel at the toe like it never really wanted the job.
They are the wrong choice if you need to get in and out of them quickly, through a door, off a train, past security, anywhere that rewards speed over ceremony. Eight eyelets take time, and no amount of practice makes that faster, it just makes you faster at being annoyed. They are also not kind to a wide calf if the shaft is narrow and unforgiving, which plenty of the cheaper ones are, so don't assume your usual size solves that for you.
Where they do work is autumn and winter, with jeans tucked or over, with a midi skirt and thick tights, with anything that wants a bit of structure at the ankle to balance it out. They suit a day that involves walking rather than sitting, and they suit weather that's wet rather than properly freezing, since the ventilation that makes laces breathe also lets cold in. What they clash with is anything already fussy up top, lots of buckles or hardware on a jacket competing with lots of eyelets down below just reads as too much noise in one outfit, and they don't do delicate fabrics any favours either, a floaty dress wants a softer boot.
Before you buy, check the eyelets are actually metal and not painted plastic that will chip within a month, check the lace itself isn't so thin it'll fray at the first proper pull, and check the sole has a visible seam that looks stitched or bonded rather than just glued on and hoping. Press the toe box too, if it dents and stays dented, so will your patience. I'd start with black, plain and matte, because it goes with everything you already own and hides the scuffs you're going to put on it within the first fortnight regardless of how careful you think you'll be.
Leather BootsThe Gold Leather Lace Up Boots Your Shoe Rack Needs
The Best Looking Fur Lined Lace Up Boots Out There
Faux Fur Lace Up Boots: The Edit
Chunky Lace Up Boots: Our Honest Shortlist
The Best Canvas Lace Up Boots to Shop Now
Burgundy Lace Up Boots Picked by Us
Leather BootsOur Top Burgundy Leather Lace Up Boots Right Now
Buckle Lace Up Boots That Have Caught Our Eye
Brown BootsThe Brown Vegan Lace Up Boots We Keep Going Back ToAlso worth a lookAnkle BootsIf you're holding an ankle boot in the changing room and wondering whether it's the sensible one or…See the collections →
Brown BootsThe Only Brown Waterproof Lace Up Boots You Need to See
Suede BootsBrown Suede Lace Up Boots We Think You’ll Love
Rubber BootsShop Our Favorite Brown Rubber Lace Up Boots
Brown BootsBrown Round Toe Lace Up Boots We’d Pull On Every Day
Brown BootsThe Brown Mid Heel Lace Up Boots Your Shoe Rack Needs
Brown BootsOur Top Brown Low Lace Up Boots Right Now
Walking BootsBrown Lace Up Walking Boots We’d Pull On Every Day
Leather BootsThe Prettiest Brown Leather Lace Up Boots Around Right Now
Brown BootsBrown Lace Up Ankle Boots Made for WalkingAlso worth a lookBlack BootsI'll tell you what I tell anyone holding a pair of black boots in a changing room: sit…See the collections →
Brown BootsThe Edit: Brown Lace Up Ankle Boots
Brown BootsStandout Brown Lace Up Boots to Shop
Brown BootsBrown Faux Leather Lace Up Boots We’d Recommend to a Friend
Brown BootsBrown High Lace Up Boots That Go With Everything
Brown BootsBrown Chunky Lace Up Boots We Can’t Stop Looking At
Leather BootsThe Best Looking Blue Leather Lace Up Boots Out There
Blue Lace Up Boots Picked by Us
Black BootsBlack Zip Lace Up Boots Picked by Us
The Best Block Heel Lace Up Boots to Shop NowAlso worth a lookBrown BootsA pair of brown boots is the thing you reach for when black feels too sharp and your…See the collections →
Black BootsOur Top Black Woven Lace Up Boots Right Now
Black BootsOur Kind of Black Vegan Lace Up Boots
Suede BootsBlack Suede Lace Up Boots You’ll Wear All Season
Sock BootsBlack Sock Lace Up Boots We’re Adding to Basket
Black BootsThe Edit: Black Round Toe Lace Up Boots
Rubber BootsBlack Rubber Lace Up Boots We Rate
Black BootsThe Black Patent Lace Up Boots Worth Investing In
Platform BootsThe Black Platform Lace Up Boots Your Shoe Rack Needs
