Top Picks
Dalilah Strappy Block Heels
MAGGIE’S PICK ANTHROPOLOGIEDalilah Strappy Block Heels
$245.00 $171.50 ANTHROPOLOGIE
Laurel Heels Gold Glitter
NADIA’S PICK HELLO MOLLYLaurel Heels Gold Glitter
$119.95 HELLO MOLLY
Women Flaming June Black High Heel BLACK High Heels 41 BLACK
HANNAH’S PICK SHIEKHWomen Flaming June Black High Heel BLACK High Heels 41 BLACK
$138.26 $111.99 SHIEKH
J. Rene Women's Faleece Slingback Pump in Pewter, Glitter/Snow Dot Mesh, Size 10 M, 1.5 Inch Heel
IMOGEN’S PICK J RENEEJ. Rene Women's Faleece Slingback Pump in Pewter, Glitter/Snow Dot Mesh, Size 10 M, 1.5 Inch Heel
$109.95 J RENEE
Steve Madden Women's Tracie Jelly Thong Heels - Silver Glitter - Size
ESME’S PICK STEVE MADDENSteve Madden Women's Tracie Jelly Thong Heels - Silver Glitter - Size
$59.95 STEVE MADDEN
How we pick

These picks came from Maggie, Nadia, Hannah, Imogen and Esme, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Up to $1005 pieces
Women Quality-84 Rhinestone Ankle Band High Heels Silver High Heels 6.5 Silver
SHIEKH

Women Quality-84 Rhinestone Ankle Band High Heels Silver High Heels 6.5 Silver

$29.99 SHIEKH
−74%Women Class-H Low Heel Pump Silver Glitter High Heels 9 Silver Glitter
SHIEKH

Women Class-H Low Heel Pump Silver Glitter High Heels 9 Silver Glitter

$34.58 $8.99 SHIEKH
TinaCus Women's Handmade Glossy Patent Leather Pointed Toe Mid Stiletto Heel Slip On Glitter - US4.5/CN33/EU34/UK2-2.5/Foot Length-21.5cm / off white
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Women's Handmade Glossy Patent Leather Pointed Toe Mid Stiletto Heel Slip On Glitter - US4.5/CN33/EU34/UK2-2.5/Foot Length-21.5cm / off white

$95.00 TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Women's Handmade Glossy Patent Leather Pointed Toe Mid Stiletto Heel Slip On Glitter Pumps with - US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm / black
TINACUSTOM

TinaCus Women's Handmade Glossy Patent Leather Pointed Toe Mid Stiletto Heel Slip On Glitter Pumps with - US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm / black

$95.00 TINACUSTOM
Steve Madden Women's Tracie Jelly Thong Heels - Silver Glitter - Size
STEVE MADDEN

Steve Madden Women's Tracie Jelly Thong Heels - Silver Glitter - Size

$59.95 STEVE MADDEN
Worth the splurge9 pieces
Laurel Heels Gold Glitter
HELLO MOLLY

Laurel Heels Gold Glitter

$119.95 HELLO MOLLY
Women On The Web Heels Black High Heels 37 Black
SHIEKH

Women On The Web Heels Black High Heels 37 Black

$195.99 SHIEKH
Women Merry Grinchmas Heels Green-Bordo High Heels 36 Green
SHIEKH

Women Merry Grinchmas Heels Green-Bordo High Heels 36 Green

$278.99 SHIEKH
J. Rene Women's Faleece Slingback Pump in Pewter, Glitter/Snow Dot Mesh, Size 10 M, 1.5 Inch Heel
J RENEE

J. Rene Women's Faleece Slingback Pump in Pewter, Glitter/Snow Dot Mesh, Size 10 M, 1.5 Inch Heel

$109.95 J RENEE
J. Rene Women's Faleece Slingback Pump in Gold, Glitter/Snow Dot Mesh, Size 7.5 N, 1.5 Inch Heel
J RENEE

J. Rene Women's Faleece Slingback Pump in Gold, Glitter/Snow Dot Mesh, Size 7.5 N, 1.5 Inch Heel

$109.95 J RENEE
J. Rene Women's Soncino Ankle Strap Sandal in Pewter, Dance Glitter, Size 8 N, 2.25 Inch Heel
J RENEE

J. Rene Women's Soncino Ankle Strap Sandal in Pewter, Dance Glitter, Size 8 N, 2.25 Inch Heel

$109.95 J RENEE
−19%Women Flaming June Black High Heel BLACK High Heels 41 BLACK
SHIEKH

Women Flaming June Black High Heel BLACK High Heels 41 BLACK

$138.26 $111.99 SHIEKH
−20%Women Shimmer White Light Up High Heel Ivory High Heels 35 Ivory
SHIEKH

Women Shimmer White Light Up High Heel Ivory High Heels 35 Ivory

$159.99 $127.99 SHIEKH
−30%Dalilah Strappy Block Heels
ANTHROPOLOGIE

Dalilah Strappy Block Heels

$245.00 $171.50 ANTHROPOLOGIE

More like this

See all in Heels →
Black Comfort Heels We’d Happily Wear Out the DoorBlack HeelsBlack Comfort Heels We’d Happily Wear Out the DoorOur Top Black Square Toe Heels Right NowBlack HeelsOur Top Black Square Toe Heels Right NowGold Leather Heels: What We’d Buy NowHeelsGold Leather Heels: What We’d Buy NowBlack Flat Block Heels Edited Down to the BestBlock HeelsBlack Flat Block Heels Edited Down to the BestOur Top Beige Platform Heels Right NowHeelsOur Top Beige Platform Heels Right NowComfortable Chunky Block Heels That Still Look GoodBlock HeelsComfortable Chunky Block Heels That Still Look Good