The Asymmetric Neckline Dresses Worth Your Money

I own four of these. I’ve worn three of them a combined total of maybe nine times, and I bought every single one convinced it would be in rotation weekly. That’s the actual argument I have with myself about this category, not whether the neckline works, whether I’m buying a dress or buying the idea of an occasion that hasn’t shown up yet on my calendar.

The one that earns its keep is a dark green one that hits mid calf, the seam cutting from one shoulder down to the opposite hip like it’s got somewhere to be. Standing still in the mirror it reads almost architectural, one shoulder bare, the drape settling in a straight diagonal line, very composed, very “I have my life together.” The second I actually walk, that whole effect shifts. The higher side rides up a little at the hem, the lower side swings, and I look less composed and more like the dress is doing something interesting on its own schedule.

My brother saw me in it heading out the door once and said I looked like I was late for something important even though I was just getting groceries. That’s the whole appeal. It performs motion even when you’re not doing anything worth performing.

The one I nearly returned is a black jersey version where the asymmetry is barely a shrug of fabric at the collarbone, not dramatic, just slightly off center. Standing still, unremarkable. Walking, also unremarkable. I kept it because I told myself it was “versatile,” which is the word I use when I mean I couldn’t justify the return shipping.

You Might Also Like

My Linen Trousers Came Out Of The Wash A Different Size Than I Remembered

My Sandals Dug In For The First Few Wears Before They Finally Gave

I Nearly Ruined A Swimsuit In The Wash And Learned Something About Shrinking

Brown Or Black Leather Jacket Turned Into A Longer Decision Than It Had Any Right To Be

The one I should have returned is a structured white one with a stiff diagonal hem that looks incredible photographed from one specific angle, sitting down, at a bar, holding a drink like a prop. Standing at full height and walking normally, the hem does this weird uneven lurch, higher on one leg than intended, and I end up tugging at it every ten steps like I’m negotiating with it. It’s been worn once. It will probably be worn zero more times, and I know that, and I still haven’t taken it to the consignment shop, which tells you something about how attached I get to a good photo over an actual functional garment.

Here’s the honest tally: these dresses get bought for the version of my week that includes dinners and openings and plans, and mostly worn for the version of my week that includes none of that, so half of them just hang there being aspirational. The green one is the gamble that paid off because it moves like it means it. The white one is the gamble that didn’t. I’d still buy another one tomorrow.