Brown Or Black Leather Jacket Turned Into A Longer Decision Than It Had Any Right To Be

My sister called me on a Tuesday, which is not a day she calls, to ask a single question. Brown or black, for a leather jacket, and she needed the answer before Thursday. I told her black, immediately, no hesitation, the way you answer when someone asks your name. Then I hung up and stood in my kitchen for a genuinely embarrassing amount of time wondering if I’d just given her terrible advice.

That’s the thing nobody admits about this particular decision. It looks like a coin flip.

It is not a coin flip. I have owned, across roughly three decades of buying leather jackets I didn’t need, five black ones and exactly two brown ones, and that ratio is not an accident, it’s a record of every time I stood in a dressing room and chickened out. Black felt safe. Black felt like it went with everything, and technically it does, the way beige rice goes with everything, which is to say it goes with everything by disappearing into it.

The Case I Made For Black, And Why I’ve Come To Resent Some Of It

Black is the answer people want because it’s the answer that requires no further thought, and I understand the appeal, I gave in to it for years. It doesn’t show up in photos as a “choice,” it reads as neutral, it slots under a coat, it works at a funeral in a pinch even though nobody should ever be wearing a leather jacket to a funeral, and my sister has opinions about that too, but that’s a separate call. Black is the jacket you buy when you want one jacket and you want to stop thinking about it. I bought my first one in 2001, a boxy little biker style from a mall store that no longer exists, and I wore it until the lining gave out sometime around 2009, at which point I replaced it with the exact same jacket in the exact same color because apparently eight years of daily wear had taught me nothing about variety.

Here’s my problem with black, and it took me embarrassingly long to name it. It’s not versatile so much as it’s invisible, and those aren’t the same thing even though the marketing copy wants you to think they are. A black leather jacket over a black leather jacket over a black leather jacket, worn across a decade of winters, starts to feel less like a wardrobe decision and more like a uniform you never consciously agreed to wear. I’d like to have a word with the woman who bought that second identical black jacket in 2009, fully convinced she was being practical. She wasn’t being practical, she was being scared of a slightly warmer color, and calling it practical was just a nicer way of saying it.

Black also does something specific to an outfit that I didn’t clock until I started paying attention, it hardens everything around it. Put it over a soft sweater, over a floral dress, over anything with warmth in it, and black cuts straight through that warmth like it’s got somewhere else to be. Sometimes that’s exactly the effect you want, a little edge against something too sweet. But it’s not a neutral choice the way we pretend it is. It’s a decision with a mood attached, and the mood is usually “don’t talk to me before ten a.m.”

You Might Also Like

My Linen Trousers Came Out Of The Wash A Different Size Than I Remembered

My Sandals Dug In For The First Few Wears Before They Finally Gave

I Nearly Ruined A Swimsuit In The Wash And Learned Something About Shrinking

Faux Leather Jackets Get A Bad Reputation Im Not Sure They Deserve

Then Brown Showed Up And Ruined My Simple System

I bought my first brown leather jacket almost by accident, in 2015, because the black version of the style I wanted was sold out and I was too impatient to wait for a restock. Cognac colored, slightly distressed, and I remember standing in front of the mirror thinking it looked like something my father might have owned, which from me is not automatically an insult, my father had decent instincts about outerwear even if nothing else.

What surprised me was how it behaved with color. Brown doesn’t cut through an outfit, it warms it, it sits underneath a burgundy or an olive or a cream sweater the way black never will, it plays well with the entire autumn palette that black just steamrolls. I wore it over a rust colored dress to a dinner that fall and a woman I’d never met before told me she liked “the whole thing,” gesturing vaguely at me, which is not a review I’ve gotten while wearing black in years, because black doesn’t invite that kind of comment, it just doesn’t register as a decision at all.

Brown also ages better, and I mean that literally, not as a style opinion.

I still have that 2015 jacket, and the color has only gotten richer with wear, developed the kind of depth that a good leather boot gets and a bad one never does. My black jackets have mostly gone slightly gray at the elbows over time, which reads as tired. The brown one reads as lived in, and those are not the same outcome even though they start from the same wear pattern.

So here’s where I actually land, several paragraphs later than I expected to when I started writing this. Black if you want the jacket to disappear into everything and never ask anything of an outfit, which is a legitimate thing to want on a Tuesday when you have nothing left to give a decision. Brown if you want the jacket to actually do something, warm a look up instead of just sitting there being safe. I told my sister black on the phone, out of old habit, and I texted her twenty minutes later to change my answer to brown. She hasn’t replied yet, which from her usually means she’s already ordered the black one anyway.