Top Picks
Loft LOFT Beach Tie Strap Linen Cotton Maxi Dress
LEANNE’S PICK LOFTLoft LOFT Beach Tie Strap Linen Cotton Maxi Dress
$94.95 $56.97 LOFT
Teri Jon by Rickie Freeman Cocktail Dress - DropWaist: Green Dresses - Used - Size
FREYA’S PICK THREDUPTeri Jon by Rickie Freeman Cocktail Dress - DropWaist: Green Dresses - Used - Size
$80.99 THREDUP
Ulla Johnson Casual Dress - High Low: Yellow Paisley Pattern Dresses - Used - Size
ROSIE’S PICK THREDUPUlla Johnson Casual Dress - High Low: Yellow Paisley Pattern Dresses - Used - Size
$159.99 THREDUP
Homeyee Cocktail Dress - Sheath: Blue Graphic Pattern Dresses - Used
GEMMA’S PICK THREDUPHomeyee Cocktail Dress - Sheath: Blue Graphic Pattern Dresses - Used
$21.99 THREDUP
Lilly Pulitzer Dress: Blue Skirts & Dresses - Used - Size
HANNAH’S PICK THREDUPLilly Pulitzer Dress: Blue Skirts & Dresses - Used - Size
$31.99 THREDUP
How we pick

These picks came from Leanne, Freya, Rosie, Gemma and Hannah, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $507 pieces
Young Essence Cocktail Dress: Black Dresses - Used - Size
THREDUP

Young Essence Cocktail Dress: Black Dresses - Used - Size

$26.99 THREDUP
Joni Blair Casual Dress - DropWaist: Blue Dresses - Used - Size
THREDUP

Joni Blair Casual Dress - DropWaist: Blue Dresses - Used - Size

$18.99 THREDUP
Homeyee Cocktail Dress - Sheath: Blue Graphic Pattern Dresses - Used
THREDUP

Homeyee Cocktail Dress - Sheath: Blue Graphic Pattern Dresses - Used

$21.99 THREDUP
Lilly Pulitzer Dress: Blue Skirts & Dresses - Used - Size
THREDUP

Lilly Pulitzer Dress: Blue Skirts & Dresses - Used - Size

$31.99 THREDUP
Maeve Cocktail Dress: Burgundy Dresses - Used - Size X
THREDUP

Maeve Cocktail Dress: Burgundy Dresses - Used - Size X

$34.99 THREDUP
Matilda Jane Casual Dress - DropWaist: Brown Print Pattern Dresses - Used - Size X
THREDUP

Matilda Jane Casual Dress - DropWaist: Brown Print Pattern Dresses - Used - Size X

$18.99 THREDUP
Rare Editions Dress: Black Houndstooth Pattern Skirts & Dresses - Used - Size 6X
THREDUP

Rare Editions Dress: Black Houndstooth Pattern Skirts & Dresses - Used - Size 6X

$12.99 THREDUP
$50 to $1006 pieces
Free People Cocktail Dress - DropWaist: Ivory Tropical Pattern Dresses - Used - Size X
THREDUP

Free People Cocktail Dress - DropWaist: Ivory Tropical Pattern Dresses - Used - Size X

$73.99 THREDUP
Teri Jon by Rickie Freeman Cocktail Dress - DropWaist: Green Dresses - Used - Size
THREDUP

Teri Jon by Rickie Freeman Cocktail Dress - DropWaist: Green Dresses - Used - Size

$80.99 THREDUP
Weworewhat Blue Corset Peplum Mini Dress Blue-white-print
RENT THE RUNWAY

Weworewhat Blue Corset Peplum Mini Dress Blue-white-print

$83.00 RENT THE RUNWAY
−40%Loft LOFT Beach Tie Strap Linen Cotton Maxi Dress
LOFT

Loft LOFT Beach Tie Strap Linen Cotton Maxi Dress

$94.95 $56.97 LOFT
−40%Loft Petite LOFT Beach Tie Strap Linen Cotton Maxi Dress
LOFT

Loft Petite LOFT Beach Tie Strap Linen Cotton Maxi Dress

$94.95 $56.97 LOFT
−40%Loft Petite LOFT Beach Striped Tie Strap Linen Cotton Maxi Dress
LOFT

Loft Petite LOFT Beach Striped Tie Strap Linen Cotton Maxi Dress

$99.95 $59.97 LOFT
Worth the splurge12 pieces
Ulla Johnson Casual Dress - High Low: Yellow Paisley Pattern Dresses - Used - Size
THREDUP

Ulla Johnson Casual Dress - High Low: Yellow Paisley Pattern Dresses - Used - Size

$159.99 THREDUP
Ann Taylor Petite Pleated Peplum Maxi Dress
ANN TAYLOR

Ann Taylor Petite Pleated Peplum Maxi Dress

$179.00 ANN TAYLOR
Belted Volume Flare Dress (C252MSE332)
W CONCEPT

Belted Volume Flare Dress (C252MSE332)

$276.00 W CONCEPT
La Ligne Peplum Combo Dress Black
SHOPBOP

La Ligne Peplum Combo Dress Black

$450.00 SHOPBOP
Weworewhat Puff Sleeve Peplum Mini Dress Pink-cream-print
RENT THE RUNWAY

Weworewhat Puff Sleeve Peplum Mini Dress Pink-cream-print

$101.00 RENT THE RUNWAY
Buckle Square Neck Sleeveless Dress [Beige]
W CONCEPT

Buckle Square Neck Sleeveless Dress [Beige]

$194.00 W CONCEPT
Derek Lam 10 Crosby Peplum Shirt Dress With Tie Blue
RENT THE RUNWAY

Derek Lam 10 Crosby Peplum Shirt Dress With Tie Blue

$338.00 RENT THE RUNWAY
Ann Taylor Pleated Peplum Maxi Dress
ANN TAYLOR

Ann Taylor Pleated Peplum Maxi Dress

$179.00 ANN TAYLOR
NEEM | Tailored Cummerbund Dress
CERQULAR

NEEM | Tailored Cummerbund Dress

$379.35 CERQULAR
Fanm Mon Mireille Dress Pink-multicolored-print
RENT THE RUNWAY

Fanm Mon Mireille Dress Pink-multicolored-print

$221.00 RENT THE RUNWAY
−40%Ann Taylor Embroidered Peplum Flare Midi Dress
ANN TAYLOR

Ann Taylor Embroidered Peplum Flare Midi Dress

$229.00 $137.40 ANN TAYLOR
−40%Ann Taylor Petite Embroidered Peplum Flare Midi Dress
ANN TAYLOR

Ann Taylor Petite Embroidered Peplum Flare Midi Dress

$229.00 $137.40 ANN TAYLOR

More like this

See all in Peplum Dresses →
Standout Fitted Peplum Dresses to ShopPeplum DressesStandout Fitted Peplum Dresses to ShopOur Top Gold Peplum Dresses Right NowPeplum DressesOur Top Gold Peplum Dresses Right NowFloral Peplum Dresses That Earn Their PlacePeplum DressesFloral Peplum Dresses That Earn Their PlaceA Line Peplum Dresses We’ve Been SavingPeplum DressesA Line Peplum Dresses We’ve Been SavingBlack Peplum Dresses That Flatter Without TryingPeplum DressesBlack Peplum Dresses That Flatter Without TryingBlack Crepe Peplum Dresses You’ll Want to Live InPeplum DressesBlack Crepe Peplum Dresses You’ll Want to Live In