Top Picks
Sexy Drawstring V Neck Slit Long Sleeve Dress - Wine Red / S(4)
SIOBHAN’S PICK ZEAGOOSexy Drawstring V Neck Slit Long Sleeve Dress - Wine Red / S(4)
$28.90 ZEAGOO
H&M L.O.G.G. Casual Dress - Wrap: Brown Paisley Pattern Dresses - Used - Size
AISHA’S PICK THREDUPH&M L.O.G.G. Casual Dress - Wrap: Brown Paisley Pattern Dresses - Used - Size
$16.99 THREDUP
Elegant Turtleneck Sweater Dress Slim-fitting Belted Knee-length Knitted Dress - White / S(4)
LAUREN’S PICK ZEAGOOElegant Turtleneck Sweater Dress Slim-fitting Belted Knee-length Knitted Dress - White / S(4)
$36.99 ZEAGOO
Zeagoo Women's Baggy Floral Print Swing Midi Dress Short Sleeve Casual Beach Sundress - Lake Blue / S(4)
NADIA’S PICK ZEAGOOZeagoo Women's Baggy Floral Print Swing Midi Dress Short Sleeve Casual Beach Sundress - Lake Blue / S(4)
$26.99 ZEAGOO
Soyaconcept Casual Dress - Popover: Tan Animal Print Pattern Dresses - Used
ZARA’S PICK THREDUPSoyaconcept Casual Dress - Popover: Tan Animal Print Pattern Dresses - Used
$19.99 THREDUP
How we pick

These picks came from Siobhan, Aisha, Lauren, Nadia and Zara, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $5018 pieces
Calvin Klein Casual Dress: Gray Houndstooth Pattern Dresses
THREDUP

Calvin Klein Casual Dress: Gray Houndstooth Pattern Dresses

$22.99 THREDUP
Half Sleeve Long Dresses Women Summer Casual V Neck Midi Dress - Black / XL(12)
ZEAGOO

Half Sleeve Long Dresses Women Summer Casual V Neck Midi Dress - Black / XL(12)

$33.34 ZEAGOO
H&M L.O.G.G. Casual Dress - Wrap: Brown Paisley Pattern Dresses - Used - Size
THREDUP

H&M L.O.G.G. Casual Dress - Wrap: Brown Paisley Pattern Dresses - Used - Size

$16.99 THREDUP
Elegant Turtleneck Sweater Dress Slim-fitting Belted Knee-length Knitted Dress - White / S(4)
ZEAGOO

Elegant Turtleneck Sweater Dress Slim-fitting Belted Knee-length Knitted Dress - White / S(4)

$36.99 ZEAGOO
White House Black Market Casual Dress: Black Stripes Pattern Dresses
THREDUP

White House Black Market Casual Dress: Black Stripes Pattern Dresses

$49.99 THREDUP
F.H. Clothing Co. Casual Dress: Green Dresses - Used - Size 2X
THREDUP

F.H. Clothing Co. Casual Dress: Green Dresses - Used - Size 2X

$41.99 THREDUP
Coldwater Creek Casual Dress - Fit & Flare: Gray Floral Pattern Dresses - Used - Size Medium Petite
THREDUP

Coldwater Creek Casual Dress - Fit & Flare: Gray Floral Pattern Dresses - Used - Size Medium Petite

$24.99 THREDUP
Soyaconcept Casual Dress - Popover: Tan Animal Print Pattern Dresses - Used
THREDUP

Soyaconcept Casual Dress - Popover: Tan Animal Print Pattern Dresses - Used

$19.99 THREDUP
Zara Casual Dress: Gray Stripes Pattern Dresses - Used
THREDUP

Zara Casual Dress: Gray Stripes Pattern Dresses - Used

$37.99 THREDUP
Sexy Drawstring V Neck Slit Long Sleeve Dress - Black / XL(12)
ZEAGOO

Sexy Drawstring V Neck Slit Long Sleeve Dress - Black / XL(12)

$28.90 ZEAGOO
Zeagoo Women's Baggy Floral Print Swing Midi Dress Short Sleeve Casual Beach Sundress - Lake Blue / S(4)
ZEAGOO

Zeagoo Women's Baggy Floral Print Swing Midi Dress Short Sleeve Casual Beach Sundress - Lake Blue / S(4)

$26.99 ZEAGOO
Polka Dot Midi Modest Summer Dress for Women High Waist Short Sleeve with Belt - Pink / S(4)
ZEAGOO

Polka Dot Midi Modest Summer Dress for Women High Waist Short Sleeve with Belt - Pink / S(4)

$26.90 ZEAGOO
Rope Belt Ruffle Balloon Sleeve Dress Multi-Wear Elegant Midi Dress - Dark Green / S(4)
ZEAGOO

Rope Belt Ruffle Balloon Sleeve Dress Multi-Wear Elegant Midi Dress - Dark Green / S(4)

$36.88 ZEAGOO
Polka Dot Midi Modest Summer Dress for Women High Waist Short Sleeve with Belt - Yellow / S(4)
ZEAGOO

Polka Dot Midi Modest Summer Dress for Women High Waist Short Sleeve with Belt - Yellow / S(4)

$26.90 ZEAGOO
Sexy Drawstring V Neck Slit Long Sleeve Dress - Wine Red / S(4)
ZEAGOO

Sexy Drawstring V Neck Slit Long Sleeve Dress - Wine Red / S(4)

$28.90 ZEAGOO
Polka Dot Midi Modest Summer Dress for Women High Waist Short Sleeve with Belt - Blue / S(4)
ZEAGOO

Polka Dot Midi Modest Summer Dress for Women High Waist Short Sleeve with Belt - Blue / S(4)

$26.90 ZEAGOO
Floral Puff Sleeve Dress Elastic Waist Open Back Casual Dresses Side Split Midi Flowy Dresses - Dark Grey / S(4)
ZEAGOO

Floral Puff Sleeve Dress Elastic Waist Open Back Casual Dresses Side Split Midi Flowy Dresses - Dark Grey / S(4)

$23.98 ZEAGOO
Abbey Glass Casual Dress - Wrap: Blue Paisley Pattern Dresses - Used
THREDUP

Abbey Glass Casual Dress - Wrap: Blue Paisley Pattern Dresses - Used

$71.99 THREDUP
Worth the splurge3 pieces