Top Picks
Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Navy / Small
SIOBHAN’S PICK KOSHER CASUALModest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Navy / Small
$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Olive / Small
IMOGEN’S PICK KOSHER CASUALWomen's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Olive / Small
$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Aurora's Aria Maxi Skirt White
DANI’S PICK HELLO MOLLYAurora's Aria Maxi Skirt White
$75.95 HELLO MOLLY
Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Walnut / Medium
AISHA’S PICK KOSHER CASUALModest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Walnut / Medium
$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Sunkissed Smiles Skirt Mustard
MEGAN’S PICK HELLOMOLLYSunkissed Smiles Skirt Mustard
$79.75 HELLOMOLLY
How we pick

These picks came from Siobhan, Imogen, Dani, Aisha and Megan, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $5011 pieces
Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Olive Batik / Small
KOSHER CASUAL

Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Olive Batik / Small

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Olive / Small
KOSHER CASUAL

Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Olive / Small

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Smocked Ruffle Mini Skirts Summer High Waisted Tiered Short Skirt with Shorts - Black / S(4)
ZEAGOO

Smocked Ruffle Mini Skirts Summer High Waisted Tiered Short Skirt with Shorts - Black / S(4)

$28.74 ZEAGOO
Cotton On Women - Estelle Satin Lace Slip Mini Skirt
COTTON ON

Cotton On Women - Estelle Satin Lace Slip Mini Skirt

$44.99 COTTON ON
Masseys Luxe Satin Slip Skirt Blue Skirts 4X
SHOEMALL

Masseys Luxe Satin Slip Skirt Blue Skirts 4X

$20.00 SHOEMALL
Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Navy / Small
KOSHER CASUAL

Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Navy / Small

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Navy / Small
KOSHER CASUAL

Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Navy / Small

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Heather Grey / Small
KOSHER CASUAL

Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Heather Grey / Small

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Walnut / Medium
KOSHER CASUAL

Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Walnut / Medium

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
TOMMY JEANS Womens Beige Cotton Blend Straight Knee Length Skirt M Casual
CERQULAR

TOMMY JEANS Womens Beige Cotton Blend Straight Knee Length Skirt M Casual

$28.59 CERQULAR
Masseys Luxe Satin Slip Skirt Bone Skirts
SHOEMALL

Masseys Luxe Satin Slip Skirt Bone Skirts

$20.00 SHOEMALL
$50 to $10010 pieces
Sparks Fun Mesh Mini Skirt Orange
HELLOMOLLY

Sparks Fun Mesh Mini Skirt Orange

$59.75 HELLOMOLLY
Candlelit Lovers Gingham Mini Skirt Blush
HELLO MOLLY

Candlelit Lovers Gingham Mini Skirt Blush

$95.95 HELLO MOLLY
Lexi Low Rise Mini Skirt Black
HELLO MOLLY

Lexi Low Rise Mini Skirt Black

$55.00 HELLO MOLLY
Surfside Glow Maxi Skirt White
HELLO MOLLY

Surfside Glow Maxi Skirt White

$75.95 HELLO MOLLY
Ignite Love Maxi Skirt Pink
HELLO MOLLY

Ignite Love Maxi Skirt Pink

$59.00 HELLO MOLLY
Sunkissed Smiles Skirt Mustard
HELLOMOLLY

Sunkissed Smiles Skirt Mustard

$79.75 HELLOMOLLY
Starlit Muse Midi Skirt Black
HELLO MOLLY

Starlit Muse Midi Skirt Black

$79.95 HELLO MOLLY
Aurora's Aria Maxi Skirt White
HELLO MOLLY

Aurora's Aria Maxi Skirt White

$75.95 HELLO MOLLY
Polar Party Knit Maxi Skirt White
HELLO MOLLY

Polar Party Knit Maxi Skirt White

$99.95 HELLO MOLLY
−80%El Nido Cotton Poplin Skirt
NATORI

El Nido Cotton Poplin Skirt

$350.00 $70.00 NATORI
Worth the splurge4 pieces
After Rose Skirt - Black
JANET HOWARD

After Rose Skirt - Black

$189.00 JANET HOWARD
Karl Lagerfeld - Wool-blend Cable Knit Skirt, Woman, Beige, Size: Xs
KARL LAGERFELD

Karl Lagerfeld - Wool-blend Cable Knit Skirt, Woman, Beige, Size: Xs

$329.95 KARL LAGERFELD
−50%A. L.C. Lydia Skirt Slate Blue
SHOPBOP

A. L.C. Lydia Skirt Slate Blue

$495.00 $247.50 SHOPBOP
−40%Austin Skirt in Printed Poplin
PROENZA SCHOULER LLC

Austin Skirt in Printed Poplin

$491.67 $295.00 PROENZA SCHOULER LLC

More like this

See all in Slip Skirts →
Embroidered Slip Skirts to Build Outfits AroundSlip SkirtsEmbroidered Slip Skirts to Build Outfits AroundHandpicked Evening Slip Skirts We Keep Coming Back ToSlip SkirtsHandpicked Evening Slip Skirts We Keep Coming Back ToWhere to Find the Best Faux Leather Slip SkirtsSlip SkirtsWhere to Find the Best Faux Leather Slip SkirtsA Closer Look at the Best Black Leather Slip SkirtsSlip SkirtsA Closer Look at the Best Black Leather Slip SkirtsThe A Line Slip Skirts We’re Eyeing Up This SeasonSlip SkirtsThe A Line Slip Skirts We’re Eyeing Up This SeasonOur Shortlist of Black Lace Slip SkirtsSlip SkirtsOur Shortlist of Black Lace Slip Skirts