Claire’s Pick of the Best Black Wrap Skirts

I own four black wrap skirts right now, which honestly is not a number I set out to reach, it just sort of happened over eighteen months of me checking resale listings at 6am like it’s a part time job. And here’s the thing nobody warns you about with this category. The whole appeal of a wrap skirt, the way it looks put together without you doing much, only actually works if the thing stays wrapped. Otherwise you’re just wearing a piece of fabric that’s making a suggestion.

The disagreement I keep having isn’t really about the skirts at all. It’s about whether you live a car life or a walking life, and those are two completely different relationships with a wrap closure.

I drive everywhere in Nashville. I get in the car, I sit, I get out, the skirt has one job the entire day and it does it fine. Then I’m in New York hunting a listing in person because the seller wouldn’t ship, and suddenly I’m doing six blocks and a subway pole and a set of stairs, and that same skirt is a completely different garment. It needs an actual interior tie, not just a wrap and a hope, or you spend the whole train ride doing that little downward tug that everyone pretends not to notice everyone else doing.

Static is its own drama depending on what’s underneath. Slip skirt, no static, boring but reliable. Skirt with any lining that isn’t natural fiber, I’ve had it climb up against tights on a platform at 34th Street like it was trying to make a run for it.

You Might Also Like

My Linen Trousers Came Out Of The Wash A Different Size Than I Remembered

My Sandals Dug In For The First Few Wears Before They Finally Gave

I Nearly Ruined A Swimsuit In The Wash And Learned Something About Shrinking

Brown Or Black Leather Jacket Turned Into A Longer Decision Than It Had Any Right To Be

I keep a travel size static spray in my bag now purely because of one skirt, I won’t say which, that humbled me in front of a full subway car.

The pick I keep coming back to has a double wrap front with a real interior button, not just a tie, and I checked the stitching around that button before I even looked at the price, which tells you exactly where my head’s at these days. It sits closed through sitting, standing, the whole commute, no adjustment required, which after everything else I’ve tried felt like WINNING something.

I’ll be honest about the gamble though. The fourth one in my closet has a single wrap with a tie that sits low on the hip, gorgeous on the hanger, gorgeous in the listing photos, and it needs constant hand checking the second you’re doing actual movement instead of standing for a photo. I bought it anyway because I wanted it the second I saw the hardware was real, and wanting something because you almost lost it to another bidder is not a good reason to own a skirt, and I own it anyway.

So the real question before you buy one isn’t the color, it’s black, they’re all black. It’s whether your day looks more like a car or more like a platform.