I have two gold square neck dresses hanging on the same rod, about four inches apart, and they are the entire argument I’ve been having with myself for a month. One is a stiff satin-finish thing I bought for a date at a restaurant with cloth napkins. The other is a softer, almost matte gold jersey I bought eight months earlier for absolutely no reason except that it was on sale and I liked the neckline. The satin one photographs like a lightbulb went off inside my ribcage. The jersey one photographs like gold. Actual gold, the color, not the special effect.

And that’s the whole fight right there, whether you want the dress or the flash.
Under bright office lights, the satin dress is a problem I brought on myself. I wore it to a lunch meeting once because I hadn’t planned my week properly, and by the second hour I looked like I was radiating slightly, in a way that made a coworker ask if I was feeling okay, which is not the compliment either of us wanted. The jersey one has never once made anyone ask if I’m unwell. It just sits there being a nice, warm, believable gold, the kind that looks the same in a bathroom mirror as it does in a restaurant that’s trying too hard with the lighting.
Neither one has pockets, obviously, because apparently a square neckline uses up whatever budget was allotted for “features that help a woman function.” My phone spent one entire dinner wedged into the elastic of my strapless bra, which is a sentence I never expected to write and genuinely regret having lived. After that I started using a tiny cross body bag that does not match either dress and I no longer care.
You Might Also Like
The gamble here, and I’ll say it plainly, is the satin one on anyone who isn’t specifically looking for maximum shine and doesn’t mind being the brightest object at the table.

I had a client last year who wanted “something gold” for an anniversary dinner and I almost handed her the satin without thinking twice, then stopped myself, because on someone who runs warmer in flash photography, that dress turns into a small explosion, not an outfit. She left with the jersey instead and thanked me later.
I measured the necklines on both, because I always do, and they’re within a quarter inch of each other, same square cut, same general promise. What’s different is everything the label doesn’t tell you, how each one reads under real light in a real restaurant with a real phone problem. I keep both. I wear the jersey four times as often. I’ve stopped pretending the satin one was a mistake, though. Some nights you actually want the lightbulb.





[…] the tie point difference between the highest and lowest was almost two inches. Two inches at the neck changes everything about how the dress sits on a chest, and nobody’s mentioning that […]