There was a time, maybe three years ago, when I thought a hat on a resale app was basically a scam against your own hairline. Wide brim, structured straw, the kind of thing that looks incredible on a listing photo shot against a white wall and then sits on your hall table for four months while you pretend you’re going to wear it to brunch. That was the whole category’s reputation for me. Now I’ve got a wide brim felt one I bought off a woman in Franklin who was clearly downsizing an entire closet in one weekend, and it’s on my head more than half my shirts are on my body, so clearly something shifted, and I don’t think it’s just me.
I refreshed a listing for a vintage Gigi Burris straw for eleven days straight, mostly around 7am because I have a theory, unproven, occasionally embarrassing, that sellers relist overnight inventory right when their coffee kicks in. Somebody got it forty minutes before I would have, and I said something out loud in my kitchen that I’m not going to repeat here.
I am still thinking about that hat. I do not own that hat. I have made peace with maybe eighty percent of that.
The one I did win, the felt one, I almost didn’t buy because the brim had a slight press mark from however it had been stored, and I sat there for a full ten minutes deciding if that was a flaw or just proof somebody actually wore it instead of shelving it. Bought it anyway. Checked the inner band stitching before I even looked at what she was asking, which if you know me is completely normal and if you don’t know me probably sounds unhinged.
You Might Also Like
Here’s my honest count, it goes with four outfits reliably, maybe six if I’m feeling brave about my jean jacket situation, and it sits untouched for stretches that embarrass me, then gets worn three days running because I finally left the house before 9am and my hair had opinions. That’s the real rhythm of owning one, not constant, not never, just there when the morning goes sideways.
I’ll say the gamble part plainly, a structured wide brim is not a safe pick for someone who wants to blend in, it reads as a decision the second you put it on, and on the wrong day it reads as a costume. I happen to like being read as a decision. Not everyone does, and I’d rather tell you that than pretend it disappears into any outfit the way a baseball cap does.
The market on these moves fast and the good ones don’t sit long, so if you’re circling one, stop circling. I lost a hat to a stranger at 6:47am once. I’m not doing that twice.
