My roommate and I had a whole thing going about whether hiking boots even earn a spot in a real closet or just a spot in the front hall gathering dust between trips, and honestly the argument was never going to end, because it wasn’t really an argument, it was two people describing two different lives. Then it snowed eleven inches in one night in March, which Chicago does just to remind you it can, and the whole debate evaporated. Nobody won. The sidewalk won. We both wore boots for a week straight and never brought it up again.
Here’s what I’ll say for them, unprompted, because nobody asked.
The pair I actually reach for has a shaft that hits right at the ankle bone, not up the calf, and that one detail is the entire reason they get worn instead of just photographed once for an outfit that never happened. I can wear them with jeans cuffed once, I can wear them with a slip dress in October when I’m pretending fall in Illinois is charming instead of a personal attack, and they don’t fight either look. The taller pair I own, the one that laces up past my calf like it’s headed somewhere serious, that one has been worn exactly twice. It’s gorgeous. It also makes every dress I own look like a costume decision, so it sits in the closet with the tag still on the box, not the boot, I did cut the tag off the boot like an animal, but the box tag, still there, judging me.
You Might Also Like
I will say this plainly. If you have actual full calves, the tall shaft boot is a genuine gamble, it can pinch in a way that no amount of “break them in” advice fixes, and I spent forty dollars on wide calf inserts before admitting defeat and giving the boots to my sister, who has different calves and apparently different luck.
What winds me up is the marketing, always the marketing. A boot gets called “trail ready” and “everyday wearable” in the same paragraph, and those are not the same boot, they have never been the same boot, and somebody at these companies knows it and keeps writing it anyway. You do not get to promise me a mountain and a coffee run out of the same pair of boots and act surprised when the sole that grips scree feels like walking on bricks down Michigan Avenue.
What I actually love, no rant attached, is the moment a boot goes from stiff and unfriendly to something that just moves with you, no thinking involved. It takes longer than the box implies and it’s worth every uncomfortable week. I’ve said that to my downstairs neighbor more than once, unprompted, she just happens to be in the elevator a lot.
