Top Picks
Favorite Daughter The Hold Me Dress Black
MAGGIE’S PICK SHOPBOPFavorite Daughter The Hold Me Dress Black
$288.00 SHOPBOP
Goddiva One Shoulder Organza Fan Detail Lace Bodice Midi Dress
FREYA’S PICK GODDIVAGoddiva One Shoulder Organza Fan Detail Lace Bodice Midi Dress
$69.00 GODDIVA
The Hype Off Shoulder Satin Midi Dress Black
GEMMA’S PICK HELLO MOLLYThe Hype Off Shoulder Satin Midi Dress Black
$119.95 HELLO MOLLY
Black 3d Rose One-Shoulder Midi Dress, BLACK
MEGAN’S PICK FARMRIOBlack 3d Rose One-Shoulder Midi Dress, BLACK
$420.00 FARMRIO
Wishlist Cocktail Dress - Sheath: Black Solid Pattern Dresses - Used
SIOBHAN’S PICK THREDUPWishlist Cocktail Dress - Sheath: Black Solid Pattern Dresses - Used
$23.99 THREDUP
How we pick

These picks came from Maggie, Freya, Gemma, Megan and Siobhan, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $507 pieces
ASOS Design Cocktail Dress: Black Dresses - Used - Size
THREDUP

ASOS Design Cocktail Dress: Black Dresses - Used - Size

$22.99 THREDUP
Sexy Solid Color Ruched One Shoulder Midi Bodycon Dress
UNIQUE KULTURE AFFILIATE PROGRAM

Sexy Solid Color Ruched One Shoulder Midi Bodycon Dress

$31.79 UNIQUE KULTURE AFFILIATE PROGRAM
Goddiva Bardot Pleated Midi Dress
GODDIVA

Goddiva Bardot Pleated Midi Dress

$48.00 GODDIVA
Fashion Nova Cocktail Dress: Black Dresses - Size 2X
THREDUP

Fashion Nova Cocktail Dress: Black Dresses - Size 2X

$18.99 THREDUP
Express Cocktail Dress: Black Dresses - Size
THREDUP

Express Cocktail Dress: Black Dresses - Size

$15.99 THREDUP
Wishlist Cocktail Dress - Sheath: Black Solid Pattern Dresses - Used
THREDUP

Wishlist Cocktail Dress - Sheath: Black Solid Pattern Dresses - Used

$23.99 THREDUP
Busayo Collective Cocktail Dress: Black Tie-dye Pattern Dresses - Used - Size
THREDUP

Busayo Collective Cocktail Dress: Black Tie-dye Pattern Dresses - Used - Size

$49.99 THREDUP
$50 to $1005 pieces
BASE The High Neck Ribbed Bodycon Midi Dress Black
HELLO MOLLY

BASE The High Neck Ribbed Bodycon Midi Dress Black

$59.95 HELLO MOLLY
Goddiva One Shoulder A Line Midi Dress
GODDIVA

Goddiva One Shoulder A Line Midi Dress

$95.00 GODDIVA
Goddiva One Shoulder Organza Fan Detail Lace Bodice Midi Dress
GODDIVA

Goddiva One Shoulder Organza Fan Detail Lace Bodice Midi Dress

$69.00 GODDIVA
Rachel Comey Cocktail Dress: Black Polka Dots Pattern Dresses - Used - Size
THREDUP

Rachel Comey Cocktail Dress: Black Polka Dots Pattern Dresses - Used - Size

$89.99 THREDUP
−80%DL1961 Esme One Shoulder Coated Midi Dress black coated (highluxe)
SHOPBOP

DL1961 Esme One Shoulder Coated Midi Dress black coated (highluxe)

$359.00 $71.80 SHOPBOP
Worth the splurge13 pieces
Rebecca Vallance After Hours Midi Dress Black
RENT THE RUNWAY

Rebecca Vallance After Hours Midi Dress Black

$303.00 RENT THE RUNWAY
Leading Lights One Shoulder Bandage Midi Dress Black
HELLO MOLLY

Leading Lights One Shoulder Bandage Midi Dress Black

$105.00 HELLO MOLLY
Favorite Daughter The Hold Me Dress Black
SHOPBOP

Favorite Daughter The Hold Me Dress Black

$288.00 SHOPBOP
Rosetta Getty x RTR One Shoulder Midi Dress Black
RENT THE RUNWAY

Rosetta Getty x RTR One Shoulder Midi Dress Black

$149.00 RENT THE RUNWAY
Giving Luxe Midi Dress Black
HELLOMOLLY

Giving Luxe Midi Dress Black

$129.75 HELLOMOLLY
V Neck Collar Button Dress (Black)
W CONCEPT

V Neck Collar Button Dress (Black)

$210.00 W CONCEPT
HELLO MOLLY Hollywood Calling Satin One Shoulder Midi Dress White
HELLO MOLLY

HELLO MOLLY Hollywood Calling Satin One Shoulder Midi Dress White

$109.95 HELLO MOLLY
Black 3d Rose One-Shoulder Midi Dress, BLACK
FARMRIO

Black 3d Rose One-Shoulder Midi Dress, BLACK

$420.00 FARMRIO
Adorabelle One Shoulder Midi Dress Black
HELLOMOLLY

Adorabelle One Shoulder Midi Dress Black

$105.95 HELLOMOLLY
Essence Of Class One Shoulder Midi Dress Black
HELLO MOLLY

Essence Of Class One Shoulder Midi Dress Black

$115.00 HELLO MOLLY
Gerri Off Shoulder Maxi Dress
PETAL & PUP

Gerri Off Shoulder Maxi Dress

$109.00 PETAL & PUP
The Hype Off Shoulder Satin Midi Dress Black
HELLO MOLLY

The Hype Off Shoulder Satin Midi Dress Black

$119.95 HELLO MOLLY
−40%Merlette Lilou Dress Black X
SHOPBOP

Merlette Lilou Dress Black X

$360.00 $216.00 SHOPBOP

More like this

See all in One Shoulder Dresses →
Fringe One Shoulder Dresses That Make Getting Dressed EasyOne Shoulder DressesFringe One Shoulder Dresses That Make Getting Dressed EasyA Line Mini One Shoulder Dresses That Flatter Without TryingOne Shoulder DressesA Line Mini One Shoulder Dresses That Flatter Without TryingCream One Shoulder Dresses That Do All the Work for YouCream DressesCream One Shoulder Dresses That Do All the Work for YouBurgundy One Shoulder Evening Dresses We’d Buy AgainBurgundy DressesBurgundy One Shoulder Evening Dresses We’d Buy AgainBlue Strappy One Shoulder Dresses You’ll Want to Live InOne Shoulder DressesBlue Strappy One Shoulder Dresses You’ll Want to Live InHandpicked Black One Shoulder Lace Dresses We Keep Coming Back ToOne Shoulder DressesHandpicked Black One Shoulder Lace Dresses We Keep Coming Back To