A client came in for a fitting last spring, saw the burgundy tank folded on my rack, and said “oh, that’s a good color on nobody I’ve ever met.” Which, rude, but also the exact opening argument I needed for this piece, because half of what I think about burgundy tanks was formed in direct opposition to that comment.
I didn’t even want to like these. My first burgundy tank, bought four years ago from a mall store I won’t name because they’ve since rebranded twice, pilled at the underarm within three wears and the color went from wine to something closer to dried blood by wash six. I wrote off the whole category. Told anyone who’d listen that burgundy tanks were a trap, that the color only exists to make cheap cotton look expensive in a photo and then betray you in your own bathroom mirror under real light.
Then I bought one on a whim because a client needed a base layer for a blazer fitting and I didn’t have time to be precious about it, and I have not stopped wearing it since.
Labeled a medium, measured it against a medium tank from the same brand in black, and they were, shockingly, actually the same. I know. I sat with that for a minute.
You Might Also Like
Here’s what nobody tells you about this color specifically. It hides a coffee spill better than white, worse than black, and somewhere around wash four the neckline starts to relax in a way that either reads as lived in or looks like you slept in it, and which one you get depends entirely on the seam construction, which most of these brands treat as an afterthought. The good ones reinforce that neck seam. The bad ones let it stretch until you’re basically wearing a scoop neck by summer whether you asked for one or not.
I will say plainly, because I’ve spent most of this piece being annoyed at everyone, that the one that actually held its shape through eight washes surprised me. Didn’t twist at the side seam, didn’t fade toward brick, stayed burgundy the whole time. I should say that more, instead of only showing up when something’s gone wrong.
The gamble is the fit through the chest if you’re anywhere near my size. Burgundy tanks cut close read as intentional on some bodies and read as a foundation garment on others, and I’m not going to pretend that’s not true just to sell you on the category. My client who made the original comment now owns three. She won’t say she was wrong. I’m saying it for her.
