I bought my first burgundy dress in 1994 convinced it would become what I now think people mean when they say a “signature piece,” which is a phrase nobody used yet but the intent was the same. I wore it twice. Once to a wedding, once to a work dinner I dreaded, and then it sat in the closet for six years being a good idea instead of a dress. I’d like to have a word with that woman about the gap between what she bought a dress to do and what she actually did in it.
That gap is the whole argument here, honestly. I think this color gets bought for four occasions a year and worn for one, maybe two if there’s a funeral, and I own the math on that because I’ve done it myself more than once.
My sister thinks that’s fine, that some dresses are supposed to be occasional, that’s their job, and getting annoyed at a dress for not being worn to the grocery store is missing the point. I’m not so sure. If a dress can’t survive a full day, sitting through a long lunch, eating something with sauce, getting hugged by at least three people who mean it, I don’t think it’s earned its spot on the rail, no matter how good it looks in the fitting room mirror for four minutes under good lighting.
Here’s the thing that actually surprises people. The one that looks the most expensive on the hanger, heavy, structured, a bit stiff, is often the cheap one, because burgundy hides a certain kind of construction shortcut better than almost any other color I’ve worked with. And the one that looks like a bargain, soft, a little clingy, the kind of thing that photographs beautifully draped over a chair, is frequently the one that will not survive sitting down for three hours without announcing every seam it has. I have been fooled both directions.
You Might Also Like
More than once.
The color itself has a split personality I still haven’t fully made peace with. In daylight it can read almost brownish, sensible, a little librarian. Under restaurant lighting or anything dim it turns something closer to black cherry, which is flattering in a way daylight simply refuses to be. If you’re buying this for one specific evening, try to see it in the kind of light you’ll actually be standing in, not the kind in the shop.
One of these picks is a genuine gamble, a fitted one with long sleeves that looks incredible on someone built a certain way and slightly costume like on everyone else, and I’m not going to pretend otherwise just to make the list feel tidier.
I’ve stopped buying for the occasion and started buying for the whole day around it. That’s really the only rule that’s held up.
