Top Picks
Faux Knit Denim Knee-Length Pencil Skirt with Stretch - Black / Large
LEANNE’S PICK KOSHER CASUALFaux Knit Denim Knee-Length Pencil Skirt with Stretch - Black / Large
$28.72 KOSHER CASUAL
Lightweight Knee-Length Jersey Knit Pencil Skirt with Elastic Waist - Black / Large
ESME’S PICK KOSHER CASUALLightweight Knee-Length Jersey Knit Pencil Skirt with Elastic Waist - Black / Large
$25.52 KOSHER CASUAL
G21 Womens Blue & Black Floral Pencil Knee Length Cotton Blend Skirt
TAMSIN’S PICK CERQULARG21 Womens Blue & Black Floral Pencil Knee Length Cotton Blend Skirt
$19.49 CERQULAR
The Limited Casual Skirt: Black Print Pattern Bottoms - Size
GEMMA’S PICK THREDUPThe Limited Casual Skirt: Black Print Pattern Bottoms - Size
$18.99 THREDUP
New Directions Casual Skirt: Black Stripes Pattern Bottoms
SIOBHAN’S PICK THREDUPNew Directions Casual Skirt: Black Stripes Pattern Bottoms
$19.99 THREDUP
How we pick

Every collection on Came Saw Wore starts with a pile of products and ends with a short list chosen by real women. For black knee length pencil skirt, that was Leanne, Esme, Tamsin, Gemma and Siobhan. They looked at shape, fabric, reviews where there were any and, honestly, whether it made them want to wear it this weekend. Things that look great on a model and terrible on a hanger tend to get cut. The full list underneath is everything that matched, from lots of different shops, so you can still have a proper browse.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $5020 pieces
Lightweight Knee-Length Jersey Knit Pencil Skirt with Elastic Waist - Black / Large
KOSHER CASUAL

Lightweight Knee-Length Jersey Knit Pencil Skirt with Elastic Waist - Black / Large

$25.52 KOSHER CASUAL
Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Black / Small
KOSHER CASUAL

Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Black / Small

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Joseph Ribkoff Formal Skirt: Black Graphic Pattern Bottoms - Size
THREDUP

Joseph Ribkoff Formal Skirt: Black Graphic Pattern Bottoms - Size

$33.99 THREDUP
The Limited Casual Skirt: Black Print Pattern Bottoms - Size
THREDUP

The Limited Casual Skirt: Black Print Pattern Bottoms - Size

$18.99 THREDUP
SOHO Apparel Ltd Casual Skirt: Black Argyle Pattern Bottoms
THREDUP

SOHO Apparel Ltd Casual Skirt: Black Argyle Pattern Bottoms

$13.99 THREDUP
Womens Pencil Skirt Black Knee Length
CERQULAR

Womens Pencil Skirt Black Knee Length

$18.19 CERQULAR
New Directions Casual Skirt: Black Stripes Pattern Bottoms
THREDUP

New Directions Casual Skirt: Black Stripes Pattern Bottoms

$19.99 THREDUP
Lush Formal Skirt: Black Graphic Pattern Bottoms
THREDUP

Lush Formal Skirt: Black Graphic Pattern Bottoms

$19.99 THREDUP
Shein Casual Skirt: Black Houndstooth Pattern Bottoms
THREDUP

Shein Casual Skirt: Black Houndstooth Pattern Bottoms

$9.99 THREDUP
New York & Company Formal Skirt: Black Polka Dots Pattern Bottoms - Size
THREDUP

New York & Company Formal Skirt: Black Polka Dots Pattern Bottoms - Size

$22.99 THREDUP
Faux Knit Denim Knee-Length Pencil Skirt with Stretch - Black / Large
KOSHER CASUAL

Faux Knit Denim Knee-Length Pencil Skirt with Stretch - Black / Large

$28.72 KOSHER CASUAL
Rafaella Formal Skirt: Black Polka Dots Pattern Bottoms - Size
THREDUP

Rafaella Formal Skirt: Black Polka Dots Pattern Bottoms - Size

$8.99 THREDUP
STEFANEL Womens Pencil Skirt Black Knee Length
CERQULAR

STEFANEL Womens Pencil Skirt Black Knee Length

$18.19 CERQULAR
Philosophy Republic Clothing Formal Skirt: Black Polka Dots Pattern Bottoms - Size 1X
THREDUP

Philosophy Republic Clothing Formal Skirt: Black Polka Dots Pattern Bottoms - Size 1X

$18.99 THREDUP
Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Black / XXX
KOSHER CASUAL

Modest Knee-Length Tapered Stretch Cotton Spandex Pencil Skirt - Black / XXX

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
MARELLA Womens Black Pencil Knee Length Woven Skirt UK 8 Ruffle Detail
CERQULAR

MARELLA Womens Black Pencil Knee Length Woven Skirt UK 8 Ruffle Detail

$40.29 CERQULAR
Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Black Olive Snakeskin / Large
KOSHER CASUAL

Women's Cotton Spandex Stretch Knee-Length Modest Pencil Skirt - Black Olive Snakeskin / Large

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
Mid-Calf Pencil Skirt in Cotton Spandex – No Slits - Black Snake Print / Small
KOSHER CASUAL

Mid-Calf Pencil Skirt in Cotton Spandex – No Slits - Black Snake Print / Small

$31.90 KOSHER CASUAL
G21 Womens Blue & Black Floral Pencil Knee Length Cotton Blend Skirt
CERQULAR

G21 Womens Blue & Black Floral Pencil Knee Length Cotton Blend Skirt

$19.49 CERQULAR
DEVILLE Womens Black Pencil Knee Length Polyester Skirt M Classic Formal Wear
CERQULAR

DEVILLE Womens Black Pencil Knee Length Polyester Skirt M Classic Formal Wear

$19.49 CERQULAR
$50 to $1005 pieces