Hand Picked, The Black Trench Coats Worth Shopping

One of us thinks a black trench is the most useful coat you can own. Another thinks black is the one color you should never buy this piece in, and we’ve been going back and forth on it since October, which is when the first real cold morning showed up and made the argument matter.

Here’s the thing about black trenches specifically, and it’s not really about the coat, it’s about what’s on the coat by nine a.m. I have a dog who sheds like it’s a competitive sport, and this coat, gorgeous as it is, reads every hair like it’s being personally insulted by it. My brother wore his to a coffee shop once and left looking like he’d rolled around on the floor of a golden retriever convention. That’s the case against.

You’re not buying a coat, you’re buying a lint roller subscription.

The case for is simpler and it’s the reason I still reach for mine over the camel one hanging right next to it. Black doesn’t show the city. Doesn’t show the bus seat, the rain spatter, the thing that dripped off an umbrella spoke directly onto my shoulder on the walk to work. My dad had a black coat he wore for probably a decade of winters and the thing that struck me, looking back, is I genuinely can’t remember it ever looking dirty, which is either great fabric or great camouflage, and at this point I don’t care which.

You Might Also Like

My Linen Trousers Came Out Of The Wash A Different Size Than I Remembered

My Sandals Dug In For The First Few Wears Before They Finally Gave

I Nearly Ruined A Swimsuit In The Wash And Learned Something About Shrinking

Brown Or Black Leather Jacket Turned Into A Longer Decision Than It Had Any Right To Be

That first proper cold morning is the actual test, not the store mirror. Mine did fine at the shoulders where the wind usually finds a way in, and I noticed because I wasn’t thinking about it, which is the whole point of outerwear working. The one that nearly didn’t make this list failed exactly there, a cheap synthetic belt loop setup that let cold air straight through at the collar, and it went back on principle. A trench that doesn’t handle actual weather is just a long black blazer with delusions.

I’ll say the honest part now. Not everyone should own one. If you’re rough on clothes, if you’ve got a dog, a commute involving a bike, or a habit of eating lunch at your desk over your own lap, black is going to show you exactly how rough you are, in white flecks, every single day. The people this suits best are the ones who dress a little more deliberately to begin with, who don’t mind a coat that asks a bit of upkeep in exchange for looking finished with almost nothing else on.

We haven’t settled it, honestly. One of us still reaches for it first every morning in November. The other keeps a roller by the door and mutters about camel every time the dog walks past. Both of us own one anyway, which might be the actual answer.