Open Toe Heels In Winter Got Me A Look At The Bus Stop, I Wore Them Anyway

A woman at the 17th Avenue stop looked at my toes, looked at her own boots, looked back at my toes, and said absolutely nothing, which is its own kind of sentence. It was 34 degrees. I was wearing a wool coat, cashmere gloves, and open toe heels with bare feet inside them, because the shoes matched the dress and I had already decided the dress mattered more than the forecast. I want to have a word with the woman who made that decision, except the woman who made that decision is me, forty minutes ago, and she’s not sorry.

Here’s the thing nobody tells you about the “is it acceptable” question. It’s not really about acceptable.

It’s about who’s asking and what they’re risking. I’ve been dressing myself long enough to have worn open toes in every kind of weather Denver’s willing to throw at a person, and I can tell you the actual answer changes depending on whether you mean acceptable to strangers at a bus stop, acceptable to your own circulation, or acceptable in the sense of “will anyone official stop you.” Nobody stops you. That’s the first thing to get straight. There’s no open toe police. There’s just cold, and other people’s faces, and how much you care about either one.

The practical argument against them is stronger than the fashion one

I’ll say the quiet part first, because I think it gets skipped in most of the pieces that tackle this topic head on. The real issue with open toe heels in winter isn’t visual. Nobody is actually offended by your toes. What they’re reacting to, if they react at all, is a kind of confusion, the same confusion you’d feel watching someone eat soup with a fork. It’s not wrong exactly, it’s just not the tool for the job, and it makes people briefly recalculate what they thought they understood about the situation.

The practical case, though, that one holds up. Open toe shoes lose heat fast because feet lose heat fast when there’s nothing between them and moving air, that’s just how bodies work, and it’s a different problem than looking cold, it’s actually being cold in a way that can turn into a genuinely bad night if you’re standing outside for more than the length of one bus ride. I’ve done the math on this more than once, mostly by accident, mostly by standing somewhere too long in shoes I’d chosen for reasons that had nothing to do with standing outside. Twenty minutes at a bus stop in January and I’ve gone from “this looks great” to “I can no longer feel the smallest toe on my right foot,” and that’s not a style opinion, that’s just what cold does to skin.

You Might Also Like

My Linen Trousers Came Out Of The Wash A Different Size Than I Remembered

My Sandals Dug In For The First Few Wears Before They Finally Gave

I Nearly Ruined A Swimsuit In The Wash And Learned Something About Shrinking

Brown Or Black Leather Jacket Turned Into A Longer Decision Than It Had Any Right To Be

But I want to be honest about the other side of it too, because I think the internet’s gotten a little too comfortable pretending this is purely a safety issue when it’s mostly a comfort one dressed up as a safety one. You are not going to lose a toe crossing a parking lot. You are going to be cold for six minutes and then you’ll be inside, and inside is warm, and the shoes will have done exactly what you bought them to do, which was make the outfit work, not survive an expedition. I own a coat from 2003 that’s outlasted three apartments and one marriage, and I trust that coat with my life in actual weather. I do not expect the same commitment from a pair of heels that were never built for weather in the first place. Different jobs. Nobody asks a wine glass to also be a thermos.

What I actually decided after standing at that bus stop

So here’s where I landed, and it took me longer than I want to admit, longer than the six minutes at the bus stop, longer than that whole winter honestly. Open toe heels in winter are fine, properly fine, if you understand exactly what you’re trading and you’ve decided the trade is worth it for that specific evening. That’s the whole answer. Not a rule, a trade. If the plan is door to car to venue to car to door, and every stretch of open air lasts under two minutes, wear the shoes, wear whatever you want, the cold never gets a real shot at you. If the plan involves fifteen minutes at a bus stop in actual January wind, that’s not a shoe decision anymore, that’s a decision to be cold on purpose, which you’re allowed to make, I’ve made it plenty, but you should at least know you’re making it and not act shocked afterward.

What changed for me wasn’t the shoes, it was admitting the vanity part out loud instead of pretending it was about the outfit’s integrity or whatever nonsense I used to tell myself in my thirties. My sister saw a photo from that night, the coat, the bare toes, the whole look, and just raised an eyebrow, which from her means she thinks I’ve lost the plot but isn’t going to spend the energy saying so. She wasn’t wrong to give me the eyebrow. I knew it was cold.

I wore them anyway. Not because I didn’t know better, because I’d decided the dress won that particular argument, and I’m old enough now to make that trade with my eyes fully open instead of pretending it’s a mystery how my toes got that cold.

So is it acceptable to wear open toe heels in winter. Sure. Acceptable was never really the question. The question is whether you’re willing to be a little bit cold for the length of time it takes to look the way you wanted to look, and whether you’ve stopped lying to yourself about which one you actually care about more. I know which one I picked at that bus stop. I’d pick it again, probably, if the dress was good enough.