Half of last January was spent with wet feet because I refused to accept that my pair of “waterproof” ankle boots weren’t cut out for Edinburgh slush. Spoiler alert: they’re not. It took me three miserable days of stomping through puddles of melted snow and frozen mud with wet socks to admit the truth: I needed real snow boots.
Not sad-looking booties that tried to pass as flat heels or jeggings-friendly sneakers, I needed actual snow boots that put function above fashion when it comes to keeping your feet warm and dry. But ever since trying on a pair of my friend’s wellies on a gross shopping trip home, my feet have remained miraculously dry and I’ve realised that I’ve been making winter walking far more miserable than it needs to be by refusing to accept that not all boots are built for Scottish winter conditions. After weeks spent Googling every snow boot under the sun, not only have I found my perfect pair, I’ve also changed the way I think about dressing for winter.
Here’s what I learned: Taught me that there’s ankle-high options that work just as well for city living as their knee-high counterparts. You’ll find ones that work with jeans and tights and skirts, and even some that are dress-friendly if you need something to take you from the train station to your office.
I wanted versions that provided insulation without blowing out your feet — too much style oftentimes means sacrificing practicality and warmth.
Prior were boots with sealed seams down the toe and back of the heel, because water gets in through those areas first. Skied right past anything with large fabric panels that looked like they’d absorb any liquid they touched, regardless of what the brand may tell you about their “water-resistant” properties. Made sure they had a lining I wouldn’t hate if my boots got wet.
Nothing is more annoying than a boot with a fuzzy fabric lining that can’t dry overnight. I didn’t want wet boots on my way to work in the mornings. I rejected countless boots that had permanently attached linings that would take days to dry out.
Grips were a must – an actual tread on the bottom, not the decorative look of tread that many boots have. I learned this firsthand when I slipped on a rain-covered stone staircase wearing a pair of boots that looked like they’d grip my childhood stuffed animals to my ankles but were totally smooth on any slick surface. Required rubber that actually went up the sides of the boot too.
Yes, that section of rubber (or other waterproof material) that stretches from the bottom of the sole up the sides of your boot. If there isn’t material that protects the areas where the sole meets the boot upper, water will leak through. Enter said ankle boots from January.
Taught me that if you’re going for tall, they need to cover enough of your legs to actually keep the snow out. Twice now I’ve bought boots that hit just above my calf and let snow build up over the top every time I walk through more than an inch of it. Coverage needs to work with not just how your legs look standing still, but how you move when you walk.
Looked for boots that had some kind of cinching option at the top — either a drawstring or buckle — because your calves tend to expand and contract throughout the day, especially if you’re wearing thick tights or leggings under your boots. Cut out anything that had more than two parts to the shoe lacing system. Once you’re scooping icy slush out of your shoes and your hands are numb from the cold, you want boots you can easily kick on and off.
Leave those at home. The closures had to be side-zip, buckle, or easy pull-on. Scoped out any boots where I’d struggle to pull on over bulky socks or thermal pants.
Shaft width also had to be enough to fit real winter garments. I don’t wear skinny jeans in winter, my boots need to accommodate that. Only included snow boots where that rubber wrapped all the way up to the shaft of the boot.
You Might Also Like
Wanted boots that could handle blustery winters, and that means snow. Not flurries. But snow.
Boots that could keep my feet warm and dry in Scottish winter storms. Insulation was key. If it wasn’t insulated to keep your feet warm in below freezing temperatures, it didn’t make the cut.
The biggest lesson? Boots with actual knowledge of how snow affects your feet. Filtered through my list by sole construction.
Snow boots tend to have soles that are either molded as one piece or have sealed areas where the sole meets the upper. Is it obvious where those two parts join together? Move on.
Did the rubber look like it would tear if I tried to grip something with my boot? Skip. Did I see at least one boot that could tackle ice as well as snow?
Yes! Deep lug pattern and boots made with rubber that doesn’t harden when it’s cold out.
Buying snow boots changed the way I approached winter.
I didn’t dread stepping outside when it was pouring down rain or freezing cold. I didn’t plot my walking route around potential puddles. And I stopped showing up to work with wet feet and ruined socks.
I started wearing skirts and dresses in the winter again because I wasn’t worried about my legs getting soaked halfway between my car and my office building. Better yet, I learned that once you invest in a good pair of snow boots, you really only need one. Unlike the cheap “winter boots” I’ve been buying for years that immediately lose their waterproofing or fall apart after one season, a good pair of snow boots will last.
Years. Once you stop wasting money on boots that don’t work, that starts to add up. So you can find boots for whichever Scottish winter you’re boots-for.
There’s everything from practical boots that will see you through city snowstorms to winter-worthy hiking boots. No matter if you live in Glasgow and need to commute through sludge or hike through the Highlands in deep snow, you’ll find multiple options here that are designed with one core idea in mind; winter boots should make winter life more convenient, not struggle through it looking like they can.
