My brother Sam thinks a bardot top is basically office-appropriate as long as you own a blazer, and I think that logic is how you end up explaining your shoulders to HR. This isn’t actually a disagreement about the top. It’s a disagreement about how each of us treats a dress code. He works somewhere with a foosball table and calls a hoodie “business casual.” I sit closer to the client-facing end of things, where the gray area is a lot narrower and I have personally tested its edges more than once.
I own the brown one now, a specific rust brown, not tan, not camel, and I bought it after two failed attempts in colors that photographed better than they wore. The first was cream and showed everything, including a coffee incident I’m not going to describe in detail because I’ve mostly recovered.
The second was black and looked like I was going to a funeral in a strapless dress, which is its own kind of wrong for a Tuesday. Brown ended up doing what neither of those did, it read as a top and not a statement, which turns out to be the entire trick with this category at work.
The straps are the actual daily problem, not the neckline, whatever anyone tells you. Mine has thin adjustable ones I keep meaning to tighten and never do until I’m three hours into a shift doing the one shouldered shrug that every woman in an off shoulder top does at some point, the little tug and reset that’s become basically involuntary at this point. I’ve caught myself doing it mid sentence in a meeting, which is not the confident silhouette the styling photo implied.
You Might Also Like
Underwear was its own negotiation.
A regular bra strap defeats the entire point and turns the top into a costume, so I went strapless, which held for exactly one full day before I gave up and bought a clip converter that turns a normal bra into something that stays roughly where it should. Not glamorous. Extremely necessary. Nobody warns you about this part, they just show you the top on a hanger and let you figure out the infrastructure yourself.
Sam still thinks I’m overthinking the whole thing, and for his job he’d probably be right. For mine, I layer it under a blazer or a cardigan for anything with clients and let it be a top on its own on the days I’m just at my desk, which is its own quiet office code nobody writes down but everyone reads correctly. I wouldn’t call it a safe pick. It’s a specific bet on the kind of day you’re having, and about a third of the time I still guess wrong.
