A friend visiting from Chicago picked up my green sandals off the shoe pile by the door, held them up to the window, and said “these are not the color they were on your phone,” which is exactly the kind of comment that derails an entire evening because she was right and I had been lying to myself about it for two months. In the listing photos they read like a deep bottle green, moody, almost black in the shadows. In actual Nashville sunlight they are closer to a swamp olive, which is not a bad color, I just did not buy swamp olive, I bought the idea of bottle green and got talked into the algorithm’s lighting.
That is basically the whole fight I’ve been having with myself, sandals aren’t a doorway item, they’re a distance item, and I did not internalize that fast enough. I wore them to the farmers market three Saturdays ago, roughly a mile of pavement round trip plus standing around a tomato stand pretending to negotiate, and by the end my left foot had a specific hot spot right where the strap crosses, the kind you don’t feel until minute forty when it’s too late to do anything about it.
The sound is the other thing nobody warns you about.
Mine slap. Not politely either, a full flat clap against tile that means my husband knows I’m home before I’ve said a word, he calls it my “arrival announcement,” and on concrete it echoes enough that I’ve had a stranger on a train platform actually turn around to see what was coming.
You Might Also Like
Where I landed, after wearing four different pairs across a stupid number of weekends: the ones with any kind of contoured footbed win, every time, over anything flat that just looks good standing still. The flat ones photograph better, no contest, but comfort over an actual mile of walking is a completely different contest and the contoured pair won it by a mile, pun intended, I’m not sorry.
I’ll say the gamble part plainly because pretending otherwise would be dishonest, there was one pair, a bright almost neon green with a chunky sole, that I love and that looks slightly unhinged on anyone who isn’t already committed to wearing loud shoes on purpose. My mother saw a picture and asked if I was “doing a bit.” I was not doing a bit. I was just tired of every sandal being a safe, forgettable, sensible green that disappears the second you look away from it.
So here’s where I’ve settled, buy for the walk you’re actually going to take in them, check the color in daylight before you trust the listing photo, and accept that the slap is part of owning them now, there’s no version of a flat sandal that moves quietly, and anyone telling you otherwise hasn’t actually walked a mile in theirs.
