A woman on the light rail once looked at me for a solid three stops and said, “that’s not a color, that’s a decision,” and I’ve thought about that sentence more than I’ve thought about most actual advice anyone’s given me.
She meant it as a compliment. I took it as one. But it started a whole thing in my head about whether brown shift dresses are a genuinely smart buy or just the thing you tell yourself is smart because it’s not black and you want credit for trying something.
Here’s the ledger update, because there is one. Bought a brown shift dress in April for sixty eight dollars, which felt like a lot for something with zero pattern and one seam of interest, and I stood in the dressing room doing math on my phone while the sales girl waited outside like I was in there having an emotional crisis, which, fair.
I’ve worn it nineteen times since. That’s three dollars and fifty seven cents a wear, then I recalculated because I’d carried a two wrong, and it’s actually three fifty eight, which is not a meaningfully different number but I needed you to know I checked twice.
First wear was a Tuesday, nothing special, and the mirror check was the real test, not the store mirror, the one at home under bad bathroom light that tells the truth about everything. It passed. Didn’t do that thing chocolate brown sometimes does where it reads muddy by four in the afternoon. Still looked like a decision at six, not an accident.
You Might Also Like
What surprised me is how much it argues with itself depending on what you put with it.
Black tights and boots and it goes almost severe, work appropriate, slightly librarian in the good way. Cobalt blue jacket over it and suddenly it’s doing something warmer, richer, like the brown was just waiting for a reason. A friend of mine put a bright orange bag with hers and I thought it looked like a Halloween costume for a woman who sells mid century furniture, and she wore it to a wedding and got three compliments, so what do I know.
The gamble part, because there’s always a gamble part. If your skin tone leans the same warm brown as the dress, it can flatten you out completely, you disappear into your own outfit, and that happened to my coworker who bought one after seeing mine and has since worn it exactly once. That’s not the dress’s fault exactly but it’s not not the dress’s fault either.
Mine’s staying. It’s earned its spot in the good column for the year, buy number six if you’re keeping track at home, which apparently I am whether I mean to or not.
