I own fourteen purple dresses. Fourteen. I counted them Sunday night while looking for a specific one and had to sit down on the edge of the bed for a second, because that number did not match the mental inventory in my head, which was more like “five, maybe six, a reasonable amount.” It is not five or six. It is fourteen, ranging from a plum silk slip I bought for a wedding in 2019 to a violet corduroy shift I bought three weeks ago in a moment of complete and total impulse control failure at a sample sale. There is a lilac one. There is a grape one that is basically eggplant.
There is one so dark it photographs black in every single picture I have ever taken in it, which defeats the entire purpose of owning a purple dress, and I bought it anyway, twice, because the first one got a hole in the armpit seam from a dry cleaner who should not still be in business.
Here is the thing nobody tells you about purple dresses. The dress is never the hard part. Purple is forgiving, it flatters more skin tones than any color has any right to, and it photographs like you tried without actually trying. The hard part, the part that has caused me actual standing-in-my-closet-at-7am despair on multiple occasions, is the shoe. Purple does not play nice with footwear the way black does, or navy does. It has opinions. A shade that looks incredible with a lavender sundress will make a deep aubergine cocktail dress look like a bruise. I learned this the hard way at a rehearsal dinner where I wore silver sandals with a dress the color of a plum and spent the whole night feeling like I was dressed as a grape popsicle, which, to be fair, is a specific and slightly absurd thing to feel like at a rehearsal dinner, but there I was.
So this is not a “purple is versatile, wear anything” post, because that’s not true and I refuse to write it. This is fourteen dresses’ worth of trial, error, one genuinely bad receipt, and the shoes that actually earned their place in rotation.
[Purple Dresses]
Nude Heels, and Why They’re Not the Cheat Code Everyone Says They Are
Everyone tells you nude heels go with everything. Everyone is wrong, or at least everyone is being lazy, because “nude” is doing a lot of unpaid work in that sentence. I have a pair of blush pink Nine West pumps that I bought specifically because a salesperson told me they’d go with “literally any color dress I owned,” and against my darkest purple dress, the aubergine one, they read as a weird pale smudge at the bottom of my legs, like my feet had been photoshopped in from a different, paler photo. It did not look intentional. It looked like a costume malfunction.
Where nude actually works is against the lighter end of the purple spectrum, lavender, orchid, that dusty lilac that’s basically gray with ambitions. On those dresses, a nude heel in the right undertone, and I mean actually matched to your skin, not just “the beige one from the store,” disappears in the good way, it makes your leg line look endless without fighting the dress for attention. I have a pair of camel colored suede pumps from Sam Edelman that do this job for my lilac wrap dress and I have never once thought about them, which is the entire point of a shoe like this. It’s not supposed to be memorable. It’s supposed to get out of the way.
Against the deep, saturated purples, though, nude just goes chalky and sad. Skip it. I wish someone had told me that before I wore those blush pumps to a rehearsal dinner where there are, somewhere, professional photographs of me looking like I was smudged out of the bottom half of my own outfit.
[Nude Heels]
Metallic Sandals, and the Ninety Five Dollar Gold Pair I’m Still Annoyed About
Gold or silver, that’s the actual debate, and I have strong feelings on both sides depending on the dress. Silver metallics against a cooler toned purple, the ones that lean more blue than red, look genuinely sharp, almost architectural, like the shoe and the dress are speaking the same language. I wore silver strappy sandals with a periwinkle-leaning purple dress to a birthday dinner and got a photo texted back to me by a friend with the caption “ok this is the one,” unprompted, which from her is basically a standing ovation.
Gold, though, is where it gets interesting, because gold against a warmer purple, the ones that lean toward magenta or wine, does something silver can’t, it warms the whole outfit up instead of cooling it down. I bought a pair of gold metallic sandals for exactly this reason, ninety five dollars, from a brand that markets itself as the “affordable” alternative to actual luxury shoe brands. Ninety five dollars for a strappy sandal with a glue seam that started separating at the toe after four wears. FOUR. I want whoever signs off on calling that price point affordable to explain the math to me directly, because I have seen better constructed sandals for forty dollars that didn’t fall apart before the season ended, and I will not be quietly forgetting about it.
Buy metallic sandals, they genuinely do the warming or cooling work I just described. Just don’t buy that specific pair. I did the math on this one so you don’t have to.
[Metallic Sandals]
Black Boots, for the Months When Sandals Are Not Happening
Nobody talks about purple dresses in boot season, and that’s a real gap, because plenty of my purple dresses are fall weight, corduroy, ribbed knit, heavier cotton, and sandals just aren’t in the conversation from October through February where I live. Black ankle boots are the actual workhorse here, and I don’t mean that as faint praise, I mean it as the highest compliment I have for a shoe. A black suede ankle boot with a low block heel goes under almost every purple dress I own without a single moment of hesitation, because black does what black always does, it grounds a color that can otherwise feel a little precious.
You Might Also Like
I have a pair of Sam Edelman black suede boots that have been through actual weather, not tasteful drizzle, real Chicago sleet, standing at a bus stop in November while my dress hem got soaked and my feet stayed completely dry, which is the entire reason I bought suede boots with a treated finish instead of the untreated pair I ruined the winter before. That first pair, the ruined ones, got salt stains up the side within one storm and never came clean, and I wore them anyway for another year out of pure stubbornness before finally admitting they were done.
Tall boots work too, over a slip dress, but I’ll be honest, I reach for the ankle pair nine times out of ten, because the proportion just works better with most of my purple hemlines, and I am not about to overthink a shoe that’s already solved the problem.
[Black Boots]
White Sneakers, for the Days the Dress Doesn’t Get to Be Fancy
Not every purple dress day is a dress up day. Sometimes it’s a Tuesday, and the dress is just the thing that was clean, and the shoes need to get me through a school pickup and a grocery run without a single moment of foot-related regret. White sneakers are the answer, and they’re a better answer than people give them credit for, because a purple dress with white sneakers doesn’t look like you gave up, it looks like you made a decision.
Here’s my one real complaint. I own a pair of Common Projects that were, brace yourself, over four hundred dollars, for a leather sneaker with literally zero branding on the outside, which I actually love wearing but cannot fully defend the price of to anyone who asks, including myself, at 11pm, on the couch, looking at the receipt. Four hundred dollars for a shoe with no logo. I’ve made peace with owning them. I have not made peace with the price tag, and I don’t think I ever will, and maybe that’s just me, maybe four hundred dollar sneakers are fine and I’m the one with the problem. No. Actually, no. I’ve thought about it. They’re not fine.
The good news is you don’t need the expensive pair to get the effect. Any clean white leather sneaker does the exact same visual job against a purple dress, casual, a little unexpected, done in about four seconds flat with zero blisters.
[White Sneakers]
Bold Color Heels, for the One Night You Want the Shoe to Argue Back
Every so often I don’t want the shoe to agree with the dress, I want it to say something back. A hot pink heel against a purple dress, specifically the wine colored one I wore to a friend’s engagement party, is not a safe choice and I knew that walking in, but a coworker of mine, Denise, stopped me at the coffee machine two days later just to say she was still thinking about the shoes, which is the kind of reaction you don’t get from a nude pump, ever, no matter how well matched it is.
Red does something similar, a proper red, not a muted brick red, against a cooler purple dress, and it reads less like a costume choice and more like you understood exactly what you were doing. The trick, and I learned this slowly, over multiple slightly wrong attempts, is that the bolder the shoe, the simpler everything else needs to be. No statement earrings fighting the shoe for attention. No clutch in a third competing color. One loud element, everything else quiet, or the whole outfit turns into an argument nobody wins.
I’ll admit this is the category I get wrong most often, because it’s tempting to think if one bold shoe worked, two bold accessories will work better, and they don’t, they just get louder in a way that stops reading as intentional. Restraint is the actual skill here, not the color choice.
[Bold Color Heels]
Final Thoughts
Fourteen dresses in, here’s what I actually believe.
Purple doesn’t need a rulebook, it needs you to pay attention to which purple you’re actually wearing, warm or cool, deep or pale, because that decides more about your shoe than any general rule about nude heels going with everything ever will. The chalky nude pumps taught me that. The ninety five dollar sandal with the glue seam taught me a different, angrier lesson about what brands are allowed to call affordable. The boots taught me that suede needs to be treated before it meets Chicago in November, and the sneakers taught me that four hundred dollars is a number I can spend but never fully justify, not even to myself, not even at 11pm on the couch with the receipt still open in another tab.
What I keep coming back to is that the shoe is never just a shoe here, it’s the thing that decides whether the dress reads as intentional or accidental, and that’s worth thinking about for the extra thirty seconds it takes before you walk out the door. I’m not going to stop buying purple dresses. Fourteen was clearly not a ceiling, it was a checkpoint. But I am done buying shoes on the theory that they’ll “probably work,” because probably is how I ended up looking like a grape popsicle at a rehearsal dinner, and I’m not doing that again.
