The Perfect Gold Sandal For Date Night

There’s a running joke in my group chat that I own gold sandals the way other people own tote bags, meaning too many, meaning I can’t explain most of the purchases, meaning someone will inevitably ask “which pair is this” whenever I show up somewhere and the answer is always a number, not a description. I’ve stopped being embarrassed by it. Mostly.

But here’s what nobody tells you about a gold sandal until you’ve actually sat in one for two hours across a table from someone you’re trying to impress. Your feet swell a little from the wine, your ankle gets warm under the table, and if the strap sits even a quarter inch too tight you spend the second half of dinner doing this weird under table adjustment while pretending you’re just crossing your legs. I measured a pair last spring, labeled true to size, and the ankle strap was a full half inch shorter than the pair I already owned in the same size from the same brand.

Same label. Different sandal. I wore it once, spent an hour of a date recalibrating my own foot, and never again.

The finish matters more than people think and less than the brand copy wants you to believe.

You Might Also Like

My Linen Trousers Came Out Of The Wash A Different Size Than I Remembered

My Sandals Dug In For The First Few Wears Before They Finally Gave

I Nearly Ruined A Swimsuit In The Wash And Learned Something About Shrinking

Brown Or Black Leather Jacket Turned Into A Longer Decision Than It Had Any Right To Be

Under a restaurant’s dim lighting, a good gold reads warm and expensive whether it cost forty dollars or two hundred. Under office fluorescents the next morning, when you’re wearing the same sandal with a blazer because you didn’t want to pack two pairs for a day that started with a client and ended with a date, the cheap gold can go a little green, a little brassy, in a way that a phone flash will absolutely catch and broadcast to your whole camera roll. I’ve got one pair that’s survived four New Year’s Eves and looked good in every single photo people forced me into, and I’ve got one pair that looked incredible in the mirror and turned faintly orange the second a flash hit it, which I found out at a dinner in front of eleven people.

I’ll admit the strappier, higher heeled option in this roundup is a gamble. It’s stunning on a narrower foot with a higher arch, and on someone built more like me it pulls tight across the top in a way that reads uncomfortable in every photo, not romantic. I had a client last month who wanted that exact sandal for a date and I told her, plainly, it wasn’t going to sit right on her foot, and she wore it anyway and texted me at 9pm from the bathroom of the restaurant to say I was right.

The low block heel one, though. That one got it right, comfortable at hour two, gold that stayed gold under every kind of light I threw at it, and I should say that more plainly instead of spending this whole thing annoyed.